Search This Blog

Friday, December 28, 2012

Dealing with the Borneo Agenda

CT Ali

Is it any wonder that poverty is still prevalent in the resource rich states of Sabah and Sarawak after 45 years in Malaysia?

History will tell us that alliances between states are entered into to serve strategic, economic and the national interest of their people.

More often than not these alliances are driven by political leaders who dream of greater glory and national advancement that the sum of such an alliance may bring.

History will also tell us that no nation can survive an alliance with another for too long when the interest of its people are exploited and taken advantage of by the another.

Such is the situation that the people of Sabah and Sarawak now feel they are in – the same Sabah and Sarawak that joined with Singapore and Malaya to form that new nation of Malaysia.

Joined not as the 12th and 13th states under Malaya but as equal partners having equal status and rights within the Federation of Malaysia.

Singapore has since bid adieu to Malaysia because it serves the political purpose of the Umno-led Barisan Nasional government of Malaysia for that to happen. Political Armageddon awaits Umno if Singapore was allowed meaningful participation into the federal politics of Malaysia.

With Singapore conveniently out of the way, this BN government of Malaysia did partake in and willingly encourage the following in Sabah and Sarawak:
  • First it proceeded forthwith to export to East Malaysia the politics of race and religion that had enabled Umno to divide and rule the population of Malaya to their political advantage for over 50 years.
  • Second this same BN government set out to colonise East Malaysia and took absolute control over their oil, gas and land resources for the benefit of Malaya – or more to the point for the advantage of the political elites in Umno in particular and BN in general.
  • Third they allowed with impunity the contemptible practice already embedded in the culture of Sabah and Sarawak politicians to grow indiscriminately – and that is the willingness of these politicians to indulge in party hopping and horse trading – much aided and infused by the proliferation of money politics, rampant state level corruption abuse of power and administrative management already prevalent in Malaya under the Umno-led government of Barisan Nasional.
Is it any wonder that poverty is still prevalent in the resource rich states of Sabah and Sarawak after 45 years in Malaysia?

Is it any wonder that corrupt administrators, crony timber robber baron and massive and endemic corruption now colour the politics in Sabah and Sarawak?

A political landscape that is also not unfamiliar to those in Malaya. A political landscape that any state and people will have to endure where corrupt politicians are allowed to rule not for the good of the people who elected them to office but for their own benefit.

Everyone has an agenda

For me the problems besetting our brothers and sisters in Sabah and Sarawak are no different from that faced by us in Malaya.

Today we have Jeffrey Kitinggan telling us that PKR is no different from Umno. Today there is the “Malaya Agenda” and the “Borneo Centric Agenda”. How quaint and convenient for these politicians to coin “agenda’s” because it suits their purpose to do so.

I could go into the dynamics of factions within East Malaysia that holds sway over seats in Sabah and Sarawak and their potential to make or break Umno or Pakatan Rakyat in this 13th general election but it would be an exercise in futility because these are games that politicians play to further their own interest and to make adverse the interest of other politicians.

This is what we all know.

Political change in Sabah and Sarawak happened a long time ago and Borneo-centric politics now has its own agenda.

Fundamentally it asks for government without interference from Semenanjung. Fundamentally it asks that revenue from East Malaysia be used for the people of East Malaysia. Fundamentally it asks for self-respect and a demand to be treated as equals.

Today they also talk of Umno and PKR having the same DNA.

They talk of their contempt on being lectured by the new kids on the block – Chua Jui Meng and others from PKR (only Anwar Ibrahim would past muster in as far as they are concerned but then Anwar was the one who bought them into Umno– once bitten twice shy!)

And they talk of being colonised by masters from Semenanjung.

These are but just symptoms of the malaise East Malaysia find themselves in. These political changes are what Umno is trying to come to terms with but without much success as the master-servant relationship still prevails between East and West Malaysia.

Pakatan Rakyat work through Anwar is also without much success – old wounds do not quickly heal. Pakatan listens but does not hear.

Anyhow for Umno and Pakatan Rakyat, Jeffrey Kitinggan (and possibly any political factions in East Malaysia) has made it known that they will work with the victor in the 13th general election.

It would be advantageous for Pakatan Rakyat to not forget this if they are confident of victory at the next general election. Remember in politics there is no constant. Only alliances to be forged with those who will best serve your purpose.

As for Pakatan Rakyat or Barisan Nasional wanting to form any ‘win-win’ alliances with their East Malaysian ‘counterparts’, I would suggest that for now the East Malaysian be left to their own devices.

CT Ali is a reformist who believes in Pakatan Rakyat’s ideologies. He is a FMT columnist.

76 comments:

  1. The Sabah State Government wants to see more palm oil sector players in the state, including small estates, subscribing to the production of sustainably produced palm oil under the ambit of the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO).

    ReplyDelete
  2. Berikan kepercayaan kepada BN untuk terus membangunan Negeri Sabah ini.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. BN pasti dpt membawa pembangunan yang lebih pesat kepada Sabah.

      Delete
    2. Jika BN sedia membaiki kelemahan, BN tetap pilihan yang utama.

      Delete
    3. Kepercayaan juga bergantugn sama ada BN benar berkemampuan membawa perkembangan yang berterusan.

      Delete
    4. BN mampu untuk membantu rakyat, dan memberi pembangunan kepada kita.

      Delete
  3. Sabah targets RM10mil in revenue from the three major nationwide shopping events this year.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Chief Minister Datuk Seri Musa Aman said by following the RSPO, the scope of palm oil related activities and palm oil related industrial sectors could truely attest to the Malaysian-produced certified sustainable palm oil.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Setiausaha Agung Parti Bersatu Sabah (PBS), Datuk Henrynus Amin menyelar Datuk Dr Jeffrey Kitingan atas apa yang disifatkannya sebagai kritikan tidak kena pada tempatnya

    ReplyDelete
  6. Ini berkaitan dengan sokongan padu Tan Sri Joseph Pairin Kitingan terhadap Barisan Nasional (BN), yang menurutnya mencerminkan keyakinan PBS terhadap kepimpinan dan dasar-dasar perdana menteri dan ketua menteri Sabah.

    ReplyDelete
  7. PBS pastinya kecewa dengan tindakan terbaharu Dr Jeffrey Kitingan yang mengkritik abangnya sendiri yang merupakan Presiden PBS.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Ahli Parlimen Keningau dan Ahli Dewan Undangan Negeri Tambunan memuji kepimpinan BN negeri dan persekutuan.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Apa salahnya untuk menyatakan penghargaan parti kepada kepimpinan BN negeri dan persekutuan atas semua perkara baik yang telah dilakukan demi manfaat rakyat Sabah.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hubungan baik persekutuan dan kerajaan negeri amat penting untuk terus membawa peruntukan yang mencukupi bagi projek pembangunan.

      Delete
  10. mana-mana ahli politik yang berfikiran waras akan memberikan pujian apabila wajar dipuji dan mengkritik apabila perlu dikritik, bergantung kepada keadaannya.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Buakn semua pihak boleh terima kritik walaupun bertujuan untuk kebaikan dan kemajuan.

      Delete
    2. Bn sentiasa mendengar kritikan dan suara rakyat.

      Delete
  11. Adalah kurang cerdik untuk Dr Jeffrey mengkritik begitu apabila Pairin hanya menjalankan tanggungjawabnya terhadap penduduk di Keningau dan Tambunan.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Dengan memberikan pujian kepada perbuatan baik kerajaan BN negeri dan persekutuan

    ReplyDelete
  13. Dr Jeffrey tidak boleh mengenepikan hakikat bahawa dalam banyak keadaan, PBS telah lantang menyuarakan isu-isu yang dekat dengan hati penduduk apabila perlu berbuat demikian.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Pairin mungkin jarang bersuara namun setiap kali beliau memberikan pandangan mengenai soal-soal dasar, ia sentiasa mendapat perhatian perdana menteri dan ketua menteri Sabah.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 'Pairin's magic touch!'When Pairin speaks, the prime minister listens.

      Delete
  15. Dr Jeffrey mungkin lupa bahawa Pairin ialah orang yang bertanggungjawab memberikan kata dua kepada pucuk pimpinan BN dengan merisikokan dirinya sebagai pemimpin politik kanan.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Sebagai contoh apa yang Pairin telah suarakan, menyelesaikan isu pendatang tanpa izin dan pemalsuan kad pengenalan pada 2012.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Pairin semasa tahun 1994 lagi, sudah mencadangkan untuk menubuhkan RCI.

      Delete
    2. Isu kewarganegaraan songsang masih tiada cara penyelesaian yang baik.

      Delete
    3. Kerakyatan songsang masih merunsingkan semua pihak. Kemasukan PATI yang tidak terkawal amat mengecewakan.

      Delete
    4. Harap RCI dapat selesaikan masalh PATI di Sabah.

      Delete
  17. Pairin bukan sahaja menyuarakan pendapatnya mengenai perlunya ditubuhkan suruhanjaya siasatan diraja bagi isu pendatang tanpa izin tetapi turut berpegang pada janjinya apabila meminta pucuk pimpinan BN negeri melantiknya sebagai pengerusi Jawatankuasa BN mengenai Kewarganegaraan.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Dan pujian patut diberikan kepada ketua menteri yang berpandangan jauh dan komited untuk menggerakkan sokongan BN negeri bagi penubuhan suruhanjaya siasatan diraja. Sedarlah STAR.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. semuanya terletak di tangan rakyat pada PRU nanti.

      Delete
    2. Rakyat harus bijak menilai dan membuat undian yang tepat demi masa depan.

      Delete
  19. Pujian juga mesti diberikan kepada semua parti politik komponen BN negeri yang berjaya mengambil tindakan sepadu dan buat pertama kalinya, semua pihak termasuk pemimpin pembangkang mencapai persetujuan dalam isu itu.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Jadi, ianya tidak perlukan orang yang bijak untuk melihat kenapa Pairin bersyukur kerana mendapat rakan kongsi yang betul dalam diri Ketua Menteri Sabah Datuk Seri Musa Aman, yang sepenuh hati memberikan sokongannya serta sokongan Umno Sabah di sebalik penubuhan RCI.

    ReplyDelete
  21. berbanding dengan Dr Jeffrey, Pairin sendiri bukannya baru dalam permainan politik dan beliau telah menunjukkan kewibawaannya dalam berpolitik.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Pairin telah pun berjaya menyakinkan pucuk pimpinan BN negeri dan persekutuan berhubung cadangan penubuhan RCI.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Penubuhan RCI adalah penting untuk mencari punca kemasukan PATI yang tidak terkawal.

      Delete
    2. Kawalan ketat harus dipertingkatkan untuk mengawal kemasukan pendatang asing yang tidak memiliki dokumen sah.

      Delete
  23. PBS mendapati pendekatan merendah diri Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak dalam berpolitik serta dasarnya yang sederhana dan pragmatik dengan mengambil perhatian dan segera menyelesaikan isu nasional dan negeri, amat disenangi rakyat dan telah meraih sokongan rakyat tanpa mengira kaum, agama dan kedudukan geografi.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Rakyat perlu mempertimbangkan untuk mengubah atau mengekalkan kepimpinan negara sekarang.

      Delete
  24. PBS berpendapat Najib wajar diberikan pujian atas kerja keras beliau dalam memperkenalkan dan melaksanakan dasar-dasar cemerlang seperti program transformasi kerajaan dan ekonomi, produk 1Malaysia, pembaharuan proses pilihan raya, memansuhkan ISA (Akta Keselamatan Dalam Negeri), komitmen terhadap penubuhan RCI, selain bantuan wang tunai kepada golongan miskin dan yang memerlukan, yang telah berjaya memenangi hati dan minda rakyat biasa.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Tahun inilah Najib kerap datang Sabah. sebagai PM memang wajar untuk turun padang mendekat pada rakyat.

      Delete
  25. Mengkritik Pairin kerana memuji pucuk pimpinan BN negeri dan persekutuan yang sememangnya wajar diberikan pujian, Dr Jeffery hanya mengukuhkan tanggapan orang ramai terhadap kelemahan dirinya sendiri, ataupun, kejahilannya terhadap selok-belok politik negeri dan persekutuan.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. kalau Jeffrey ni nampak sangat tiada pendirian kukuh. asyik lompat parti saja. lagi2 tidak sah kalau bukan dia yang jadi ketua.

      Delete
  26. Ketua Pembangkang, Anwar Ibrahim merangkap Ketua Umum PKR dengarnya setiap kali berkesempatan pulang ke rumah mewahnya yang berharga RM7 juta di Bukit Segambut Dalam, Kuala Lumpur seringkali melabuhkan pandangannya jauh mengelamun ke luar tingkap jendela.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Entah apa yang dimenungkannya sejak akhir-akhir ini sehingga kerap sangat mengelamun sendirian. Barangkali banyak sangat permasalahan yang sedang berkecamuk mengganggu fikirannya dan sukar untuk dirungkaikan.

      Delete
    2. Disebalik aktivitinya ke sana ke mari berceramah siang dan malam sambil menabur janji dicapati untuk menawan hati pengundi, ingatkan hatinya makin senang, rupanya makin banyak janji ditaburi makin bertambah parah lamunannya.

      Delete
    3. Patutlah semenjak dua menjak kebelakangan ini wajahnya makin kusam dan kelihatan serabut, bak kata orang tua-tua langsung tak kelihatan nurnya.

      Delete
    4. Apapun harapnya laporan berita dari akhbar Utusan Malaysia di muka surat tiga bertarikh 27.12.2012 dengan tajuk "Sebahagian besar pembelaan Nalla dikekalkan" tidak akan menambah celaru fikirannya, harap begitulah.

      Delete
    5. 10 nama yang disebut oleh Nalla itu yang dikaitkan melakukan aktiviti seks dengan Anwar terdiri daripada tiga orang wanita dan bakinya adalah lelaki yang sebahagian besarnya dikenali rapat dan mempunyai hubungan istimewa dengan Ketua Umum PKR.

      Delete
    6. Antaranya ialah Shamsidar Tahrin, Norlaila Abdul Majid, Soma Rodrigo @ Anne, Mior Abdul Razak, Sukma Darmawan Sasmitaat Madja, Dr Munawar Ahmad Anees, Azizan Abu Bakar, Ismail Mat Rabi @ Ismail Harun, Hairany Mat Nafees dan Rashid.

      Delete
    7. Kesemua 10 orang individu-individu yang namanya disebut itu tidak pun akan dipanggil saksi pembelaan bagi pihak Nalla apabila prosiding perbicaraan mahkamah bermula kelak, sebaliknya menjadi kewajipan Anwar untuk memanggil mereka sekiranya mahu membuktikan dakwaan Nalla adalah fitnah.

      Delete
    8. Tapi Anwar kekal sebagai Anwar, bijak membelit dan ada sahaja ideanya untuk melepaskan diri. Berikutan penyenaraian 10 nama ini, Anwar telah mengemukakan pula permohonan untuk menyingkirkan kesemua 10 individu itu daripada penyataan pembelaan Nalla.

      Delete
    9. Maksudnya, Anwar tidak mahu mana-mana individu itu kelak terpaksa dipanggil semasa prosiding dilakukan, jika itu berlaku Anwar bimbang ia akan membuktikan memang wujud aktiviti biseksual yang dilakukan olehnya.

      Delete
    10. Walhal, jika Anwar benar-benar tidak melakukan sebarang aktiviti seksual sama ada secara normal atau luar tabie dengan mana-mana wanita dan lelaki seperti didakwa oleh Nalla, sepatutnya Anwar perlu berani memanfaatkan prosiding mahkamah dengan memanggil kesemua mereka sebagai saksi bagi dirinya.

      Delete
    11. Dengan keadaan sekarang yang mana semua 10 individu itu kekal dalam penyataan pembelaan Nalla, mahu tidak mahu Anwar terpaksa menerima hakikat kebenaran semakin hampir. Ini tentu sahaja menambah rumitkan lagi fikirannya yang sudah sedia berkecamuk.

      Delete
    12. Percaturan Anwar sudah menemui kegagalannya, 10 orang individu yang mempunyai hubungan rapat dan erat dengannya kini umpama duri dalam daging yang bakal menghancurkan nyawa politiknya.

      Delete
  27. I think this is one way to lose yourself.

    ReplyDelete
  28. No need to dwell yourself on that thing.

    ReplyDelete
  29. As a human being, we have a choice.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Jeffrey is not believing in himself.

    ReplyDelete
  31. I do think his UBF is nothing but a waste though.

    ReplyDelete
  32. The national development agenda presented by the Barisan Nasional is better and superior than that of the opposition

    ReplyDelete
  33. The prime minister said with no experience and track record behind them, the opposition failed to prove that their alliance was stronger than that of the BN which had been tested for more than 50 years.

    ReplyDelete
  34. The BN government knows that in shouldering the responsibility

    ReplyDelete
  35. even though times had changed, the BN principle remained unchanged albeit different styles

    ReplyDelete
  36. BN have different style before, but the principle does not change, only the style changed

    ReplyDelete
  37. The government should have continuity because if there is no continuity, the government can’t make long-term plans

    ReplyDelete
  38. opposition had been instigating the people to hate the government, but democracy did not revolve around hatred, instead it was about whose agenda was better, and this bolstered the BN’s confidence to continue with the objective of developing the country and the people

    ReplyDelete
  39. To ensure effective implementation of Bumiputera initiatives, Najib said Teraju’s roles and functions would encompass several aspects and dimensions

    ReplyDelete