Search This Blog

Wednesday, April 20, 2011

You still know nothing, West Malaysians

Erna Mayuni


APRIL 20 — I am profoundly unapologetic to the people I annoyed with my column “You know nothing, West Malaysians”.

In fact, I return to annoy you once again. Because, see, many of you upset me with your rants about Barisan Nasional retaining Sarawak in the last state election.

“Sarawak gets the government it deserves!”

With all due respect, some of you have very little insight into how Sarawak works. Many of you will refuse to see the Sarawak election as nothing but proof Sarawakians are stupid and deserve to continue to live in backward conditions.

To those who think that way: I must find a rubber chicken. So I can slap you repeatedly with it in the vain hopes you will see sense.

First off, Internet penetration in Sarawak is a measly 17 per cent. So all those tweets exhorting Sarawakians to overthrow the existing government and create a tsunami — you’re mainly preaching to the already converted or the very small urban elite, many of whom quite like things the way they are.

Sarawak, dear West Malaysians, is the biggest state in Malaysia. It is not like Selangor, blessed with highways and working tar roads. Most people in Selangor and the entire West Malaysian middle class have access to electricity and running water. A lot of rural folks are not that fortunate.

It is costly and challenging to build working roads in the state. Part of that is due to geographical conditions. You cannot just blast a hole through a hill or build a highway over a river.

Seeing as Sarawak is rich in timber and other natural resources, you would think the state could fund its own development.

This is where I explain how the government works. All those resources and money from oil and rainforests?

They do not go to the Sarawak state coffer. They go to the Federal government. All your pretty roads, tall buildings, infrastructure and 1 Malaysia email accounts — guess who’s footing the bill? I’ll tell you it’s not the sand miners.

Precious little of Sarawak’s resources go to the state itself. Who is to blame for that? Who knows, really.

The simple gist of it is that a long time ago, Sarawak’s leaders signed away its rights to its own resources to the Federal government. You will understand then why I get the occasional urge to run amok in Putrajaya with a chainsaw and kerosene.

You blame the rural natives for taking 1 Tupperware and 1 Votebuying. It is easy for you to criticise them, O champagne nationalists. You tweet angrily from that cushy chair in Starbucks while the poor farmer gratefully takes the RM200 handout that will feed his family for a month.

It is hard to contemplate the future on an empty stomach.

Baru Bian lost elections twice before he finally won his seat. If a native took eight years of hard work to make inroads, why do Pakatan Rakyat supporters delude themselves into believing that one month of campaigning is enough to win them Sarawak?

You whine, you curse, you call the natives stupid but what have you done for them? It took a Swiss activist, Bruno Manser, to unite the Penans and educate them about their legal rights. Manser leaves behind a legacy and, sadly, a likely dead body. It is widely believed his corpse lies in some ditch somewhere, victim to one of the timber gangs he angered.

I remember in school I asked my (West Malaysian) teacher why the government couldn’t just leave the Penans in peace and let them keep their land and traditions.

“Oh, the Penans are ignorant. They do not understand that development is important.”

I understand now that the Penans were never regarded as anything but impediments to the thing we worship most above God — development. Our rainforests are dwindling? They must make way to development. The rare earth mine could be a potential health hazard? Public safety must be set aside for development.

We sacrifice the things we cannot replace — people, traditions, nature — for the sake of wealth. Must I point out how little of that wealth trickles down to the people who suffer most from our grand efforts?

And I put this to you — you complain only now about the government and its excesses because you can no longer take for granted your comfortable lives.

You never cared about Sarawak but for your own selfish concerns and your fears. It took rising prices and economic insecurity to make you spare any thought for Sarawak, which is frankly quite pathetic.

The many people on Twitter claiming to be praying for Sarawak: Will you stop praying for them now when they need it more than ever? Or perhaps you should instead pray for the courage to get out of your armchairs and do more than whine

32 comments:

  1. Say NO to party Malaya. UMNO, GERAKAN, MCA, PKR, DAP and PAS must be OUT from Sabah in the coming GE13.

    Enough is enough!

    ReplyDelete
  2. wow...playing division now huh? just like how uMNO divide Malay, Chinese and Indians...good work!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Well spoken article! The malayan party will never respect and Honor the 20 points Malaysian agreement. It's time for them to Get Lost with their Ketuanan sicko mentality!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Sarawak people are smart but Sabahans are stupid for blindly supporting UMNO and its stooge Musa Aman.

    ReplyDelete
  5. well, for all those west malaysian so called politician, GET OUT of this land will ya, u all are jz using us, the sarawak & sabah ppl to fullfil yur own so called 'SAFE MALAYSIA'project, after u gt it, u will never care bout wat happen to us, jz like wat d gov did b4 GE.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Too much injustice with bn/umno. their policy are as dirty as 'pig vomit' and venomous than king cobra. Their tax are worse than loansharks@ahlong. No to ISA, no to cabotage policy, no to overtaxing, no to bla...bla..bla...

    ReplyDelete
  7. West Malaysians does not understand what East Malaysians need.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Great article, you have express what Sabahan and Sarawakians wanted to say.

    ReplyDelete
  9. hanya orang tempatan yang memahami keadaan penduduknya. begitulah juga di Sabah dan Sarawak. Sabah dan Sarawak pasti boleh maju jika mereka sendiri yang memerintah.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Sarawakians know better.

    ReplyDelete
  11. usaha untuk membangunkan Sabah dan Sarawak perlu dilakukan berterusan.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Semoga Sabah dan Sarawak akan menjadi lebih membangun pada masa akan datang.

    ReplyDelete
  13. The message is clear;don't accuse Sabahan & Sarawakian of being stupid because they are voting for BN....

    ReplyDelete
  14. Good article. This is the first time I finish reading an article. That's how interesting the article is.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I hope the west malaysians get to read this article.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Sabah dan sarawak pasti tau bagaimana untuk terus maju.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Apa yang terjadi telah pun terjadi.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Apa pun kenapa tidak dari dulu lagi menolak parti ini??Sekarang sudah terlambat. Apa pun kita tengok sekarang negeri kita tambah mahu dengan adanya parti luar ini membantu. Untuk kebaikkan kita tidak salah kita memberikan sokongan kepada mereka. PArti luar tapi pemimpinnya adalah orang kita sendiri.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Sabah and Sarawak should be more rich than WM.

    ReplyDelete
  20. even the west malaysians read this article, do they care? sure they don't because it is not their problem..its better to mind own business than worrying about the others.

    ReplyDelete
  21. well, the message is clear...

    ReplyDelete
  22. just hoping sabah and sarawak will be better in the future.

    ReplyDelete
  23. all talk only but nothing happened...put your butt on your nice computer chair and surf internet... all are empty comments..who dare..challenge to you all

    ReplyDelete
  24. DAP- dYING aPEMAN pATRONIZER

    ReplyDelete
  25. hantu jual karipapApril 23, 2011 at 8:19 AM

    all Malaysia political parties only fighting for their own interest especially for power and wealth..

    ReplyDelete
  26. Pandai-pandai kamurang membuat penilaian.

    ReplyDelete
  27. I don't think West Malaysians know anything about what's happening in here.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Kalah menang adat pertandingan.

    ReplyDelete
  29. There is nothing to exaggerate about, anymore.

    ReplyDelete