Search This Blog

Thursday, August 23, 2012

RCI to oil royalty review – is BN sincere?

Joseph Bingkasan

The opposition in Sabah is questioning Chief Minister Musa Aman's sudden turnaround and push for higher oil royalties. 

KOTA KINABALU: With the approach of the 13th general election, various issues in Sabah once considered too hot to handle by the Barisan Nasional government are being picked up without inhibition by the same leaders, triggering questions of sincerity.

First came the Royal Commission of Inquiry (RCI) on the dramatic increase in the population of Sabah, an issue the federal government had shied away from for decades.

Now hot on its heels is the sudden readiness of state BN leaders to ask the federal government to raise the pittance it is paying for the state’s oil wealth to a fairer level.

Both issues were ignored by Sabah Chief Minister Musa Aman until recently and opposition politicians are asking, why now?

State Reform Party (STAR) Sabah chairman Jeffrey Kitingan fired the first salvo by questioning Musa’s sudden about-turn on the 5% oil royalty issue when he had previously been adamant that it was not an issue as the federal government was pouring money into the state in other ways.

Jeffrey said he hoped that the review Musa was asking for was not a mere election gimmick to hoodwink the voters in Sabah.

MP for Sepangar Eric Majimbun agrees with Jeffrey. He said suddenly the state government leaders seem to be panicking and paying attention to the Sabah electorate’s grievances.

Majimbun, who is also Sabah Progressive Party (SAPP) deputy president, said the timing of these climb-downs by the state government was suspect.

Prime Minister Najib Tun Razak will be in Sabah next month and Majimbun believes that he will announce the federal government’s commitment to study the proposals to calm Sabahans who are said to be turning away from the ruling coalition in droves.

Speaking to FMT yesterday, he said: “In view of the coming 13th general election, doesn’t this look like a bit of `sandiwara’ (soap opera) in action just like the government’s announcement on the formation of the RCI on the illegal immigrant problems in Sabah?”

“Najib might even announce the government’s approval in principle to increase the oil royalty to 20% as demanded by the oppositions or even to 30%” to buy and help the state governments get re-elected.

Musa’s excuse


According to Majimbun, as chief executive of the state government, Musa could have just made a demand for an increase in the oil royalty without first tabling such a demand for approval from the State Legislative Assembly.

“Going through the State Assembly is just an excuse. Musa, as Sabah Umno and BN chief, is just not bothered or worried about the well-being of the people of Sabah,” he said.

He said Sarawak Chief Minister Taib Mahmud was way ahead on the matter compared to his counterpart as he did not bring the matter to the assembly because as he is the chief minister it is his responsibility to shoulder the demands of the people.

“Musa should just do likewise,” Majimbun said.

He pointed out that Taib was even willing to put politics aside by having discussion with state leaders from both sides of the political divide and strike common ground on the issue for the good of the people of Sarawak.

Majimbun said his party had been vocal about this for years and its resolution was long overdue.

94 comments:

  1. Everyone is free to make suggestions but suggestions should be reasonable. As Malaysians, we must be fair with the federal government because we are one country. Whatever income we have, we need to share with the other states

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We are NOT the other state without us SABAH SARAWAK MALAYSIA does not exits while the other states(as u said) should not have equal shares as SAbah AND sarawak lol

      Delete
    2. ya la...kita juga harus lebih adil kepada rakyat sabah...

      Delete
    3. people first performance now...

      Delete
    4. One country Malaya with 2 colonies Sabah Sarawak used as oil pumps to fuel Malayan development.

      It is a joke to beg for fair for the "federal gov't" when they have taken 100% of our oil & give us peanuts. Have not we been too fair to them for 49 years.

      Do we want them continue sucking out our resource for another 50 years. The oil wealth is being used to enrich UMNO members and their cohorts through various development schemes and companies linked to Petronas. They are parasites feeding off Sabah and Sarawak.

      It is time to be fair to ourselves and take back our resources and use it to raise our living standards and welfare.

      Yes, without Sabah and Sarawak there will be no Malaysia!

      Let us unite and make that happen. Take back our country!

      Delete
    5. Well I must say that the Federal Government should be fair to Sabah and Sarawak. We are the big contributors after all

      Delete
    6. Talking about fairness, Petronas Twin Tower should belong to Sabah & not some plc owned by umno cronies as such was developed by funds from Sabah, much so will be PLUS, Petronas Dagangan & Chemical, almost half of all GLCs listed in Bursa.

      Delete
    7. Bagi saya rasanya tidak perlulah RCI untuk Royalti minyak ini. Tambahan lagi royalti minyak ini cuma satu perkara yang memerlukan persetujuan kedua-dua pihak antara kerajaan Negeri dan Persekutuan.

      Delete
    8. Berapa banyak RCI juga yang diperlukan? Hujung2 tiada kesudahan. TOR pun lama mahu buat, masa untuk buat siasatan lagi, masa untuk buat tindakan..bla bla

      Delete
    9. Lebih baik kaji semula Akta Petroleum 1976 tu. mana2 yang sudah tidak boleh digunapakai dan perlu perubahan, itulah yang akan dibuat nanti.

      Delete
    10. Aktya petroleum harus dikaji semula dan sedia mengambil tindakan yang wajar jika perlu diubah suai.

      Delete
    11. Kelemahan akta yang serba berkurangan harus diperbaiki lagi.

      Delete
  2. A petroleum royalty review, which may pave the way for the State Government to discuss a new rate, is indeed timely.Should the discussions materialise and succeed, it would give Sabah the financial boost for new developments and would also benefit the people

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. memang lah...rasanya memang patut royalti minyak dinaikkan..serahkan kepada musa aman untuk tindakan selanjutnya..

      Delete
    2. i agree...i think its about time for the oil royalty to be increased..

      Delete
    3. "..serahkan kepada musa aman untuk tindakan" ??? <--- kenyataan yang sangat bodoh...

      Inilah masanya kita mengubah dan menukar kerajaan, jangan lagi di perbodohkan....hapuskan BN/umNO...

      T U K A R.............................!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

      Delete
    4. Indeed. This is a good move to make sure Sabah is getting what it deserves.

      Delete
    5. Royalti minyak memang perlu dinaikkan lagi. Masa berlalu, mesti ada kemajuan atau peningkatan. Takkan makin menurun pula kan? Begitu juga dengan royalti minyak. Get a win-win situation.

      Delete
  3. "He said Sarawak Chief Minister Taib Mahmud was way ahead on the matter compared to his counterpart as he did not bring the matter to the assembly because as he is the chief minister it is his responsibility to shoulder the demands of the people."

    C'MON!

    WHEN DID TAIB EVER CONSULT THE PEOPLE ON ANYTHING LEAST OF ALL HIS OBSESSION WITH DAMS?

    DON'T FORGET ALL OF THEM ARE SNAKE OIL SALESMEN & THEY FORGET ONCE THEY GET RE-ELECTED.

    WHAT MORE, THE OIL SHOULD BELONG TO US IN SABAH & SARAWAK 100%

    ALL THIS 20% THINGS ARE NONSENSE JUST TO RAISE OUR HOPES!

    WE WILL REMAIN MALAYA'S PETROL PUMPS FOR ANOTHER 50 YEARS!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. then, what is ur suggestion?

      Delete
    2. venny : Tukarlah sayang.............kita pilih kerajaan baru. keluarkan UMno dari sabah...

      You sayang Sabah kan... kita sayang, sama-sama sayangkan sabah...

      tukar......

      Delete
  4. The Sabah Youth Council (SYC) has lauded the setting up of the Royal Commission of Inquiry (RCI)on Illegal Immigrants in Sabah saying it will boost the people's confidence in the Barisan Nasional (BN) government.

    ReplyDelete

  5. Its president Kevin Lim said it showed that the government really listened to the people.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's only a show to fool the people.
      No Action Talk Only.

      Delete
    2. Now is Musa talking, so don't you believe?

      Delete
    3. Musa only talks when BN talks.

      BN talks for 49 years and Sabah kept losing for 49 years.

      You expect us to believe after 49 years ?

      Delete
    4. Akta ini tidak memihak kepada rakyat di Sabah. Kerajaan negeri harus bertindak.

      Delete
  6. The RCI is significant as it is something that the people have been requesting for. The findings by the panel will finally answer questions that had been playing on the people's minds.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is significant for the people in Sabah so I don't think the opposition realized this.

      Delete

  7. For this, the people will regard the government as truly sincere in wanting to find a solution to the illegal immigrant dilemma in Sabah.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That has been said 30 years ago.

      Today the problem still persisting.

      Will the people be fool again by the BN government?

      Delete

  8. Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak announced last Saturday that the RCI panel headed by former High Court Judge of Sabah and Sarawak Tan Sri Steve Shim Lip Kiong had six months to complete its investigation on the influx of illegal immigrants in Sabah.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Lim said he hoped the Terms of Reference (TOR) outlined in the RCI, which comprehensively encompassed all relevant aspects, would satisfy all quarters.

    ReplyDelete

  10. The council also hoped that the government would duly act on the recommendations and proposals that would be submitted by the panel.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Meanwhile, Dynamic Interior Youth Association deputy president Rosie Jumat said all parties should allow the panel to conduct its investigation with liberty and not politicise the issue.

    ReplyDelete

  12. "We grew up with the RCI issue being relentlessly harped on by our local leaders especially from among the Kadazandusun Murut community.

    ReplyDelete

  13. "With the RCI, it is clear that the federal government wants to safeguard the future and security of Malaysian citizens in Sabah," she said.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. we hope the problem will be solved for the sake of today and future generation.

      Delete
    2. Isu kewarganegaraan harus ditanggani.

      Delete
  14. She said the association hoped the panel would leave no stone unturned in nailing the culprits who must be brought to justice.

    ReplyDelete
  15. While Lawyers for Liberty in principle supports the setting up of the Royal Commission of Inquiry (RCI) on immigration problems in Sabah, it views with concern the escalating rhetoric and demands surrounding the RCI that may have serious repercussion on the lives and human rights of some of the most vulnerable people in Sabah including undocumented women and street children of refugee/ migrant descent.

    ReplyDelete
  16. "Majimbun said his party had been vocal about this for years and its resolution was long overdue. "

    wow, majimbun is trying to get all the credit...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. semua mau jadi hero sekarang ini. jadi rakyat pandai2 lah nilai.

      Delete
  17. Many live in poverty and a life of exploitation, unable to access basic social services but are also unfairly blamed and easily targeted by politicians for social ills in the state.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. most of the politicians rise up the issue just for their politics interest.

      Delete
    2. Untuk menangani masalah kemiskinan, kita memerlukan satu pelan jangka panjang dan usaha yang berterusan. Harap tiada pihak yang sengaja mempolitikkan isu kemiskinan ini.

      Delete
    3. Isu kemiskinan amat rumit, ia berkait dengan ekonomi negara, hal individu, politik dll.

      Delete

  18. It goes without saying that all citizenship matters including grant of citizenship, identity documents and registration in the electoral roll must be conducted properly and in accordance with established laws, regulations and practises and not through corrupt practises, fraud or for improper political gains.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Sabah like any other bustling frontier territory attracts both short and long term cross border migration, some who have entered and stayed legally, while others illegally.

    ReplyDelete
  20. However, in our endeavour to enquire into wrongful past practises, we must be mindful that these are generations of migrants and refugees with varying histories and circumstances, many of whom have permanently settled in Sabah, inter married, born or lived all their lives in the state.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Consequently, these people may have properly acquired citizenship or permanent resident status and all the accompanying rights.

    ReplyDelete
  22. They have a relevant and genuine link with Sabah/Malaysia (through birth, habitual residence, descent, marriage or naturalisation) and rights under Malaysian and international law including not to be made stateless, freedom from arbitrary arrest/detention, torture, inhumane and other degrading treatment and right to life.

    ReplyDelete
  23. While the issues at stake are serious and have far reaching consequences, the citizenship and fundamental human rights of persons should not be sacrificed for the sake of political mileage or sensationalism.

    ReplyDelete

  24. Lawyers for Liberty therefore calls for all parties to remain level headed and not let prejudicial, racist or xenophobic sentiments to slant the enquiry which should be conducted objectively and based on all available evidence, testimonies and legal norms.

    ReplyDelete
  25. ini semua rethoric semata-mata...

    ada udang di sebalik mee...... peliklah...

    berberapa jenis pembohongan demi untuk mengekalkan fix deposit yang sedang cair.

    ini kalilah.....

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kalau pembangkang yang minta, sampai bila2 pun tidak kena kasi naik tu royalti minyak.

      Delete
    2. Tunggulah dan lihat dulu, tidak tahu apa yang akan terjadi nanti, fikirkan yang positif mana tahu kerajaan Pusat sanggup menaikkan % royalti kita.

      Delete
  26. If successful the people of Sabah will benefit from this.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Well it is time to consider this for the sake of the people.

    ReplyDelete
  28. The government has come to hear the voice of the people.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If really the government hear the people voice, the loyalty should not maintain 5% for so many years.

      Delete
    2. Isu loyalti seharus dikaji agar jumlah loyalti dapat diperbaiki lagi demi rakyat demi masa depan Sabah.

      Delete
  29. Why now doesn't matter as long as it is approved and leads to development of the state.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Then let justice previal as proposed.

    ReplyDelete
  31. If BN is sincere, Sabah will not be left behind...only when they need us and that is now, that they try again to hoodwink Sabahans just to get back into power...then continue their journey of corruption, federalism, economic monopoly etc..VOTE BN-UMNO AND YOU WILL SUFFER! NOT ONLY YOU! BUT YOUR FUTURE GENERATIONS WILL BLAME YOU FOR NOT VOTING BN OUT, OUT, OUT!

    ReplyDelete
  32. Ikhlas atau tidak, belakang kira. Yang penting kena naik itu royalti minyak. Kalau kena naik, masih mahu marah2?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yang penting roylati minyak boleh dinaikkan, Sabah dan Sarawak berhak mendapatkan royalti yang lebih tinggi daripada 5%. Harap Kerajaan Sabah akan berusaha membuat rundingan dengan PM kita.

      Delete
  33. There should be a win-win situation. Sabah doesn't have to beg for oil royalty increment since Sabah is the source. Be fair and give what Sabah deserves.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is a good opportunity for Sabah and Sarawak to demand higher royalties, hopefully the discussion with the Federal Government will bear fruits.

      Delete
    2. Kerajaan negeri harus memperjuangkan demi rakyat di Sabah.

      Delete
  34. Ini pandangan IKHLAS dari saya.Dr.Jeffrey patut diberi pujian.Memang patut..Kenapa beliau diberi pujian...? kerana beliaulah selama ini telah bermati-matian menyedarkan kepada pemimpin baik dipehak BN atau lain-lain pembangkang termasuk PKR.yang Sehingga pemimpin-pemimpin BN mentertawakan dan memperlekihkan perjuangan beliau dan dianggap sebahgian besar oleh pemimpin khususnya UMNO termasuk komponen BN lain ,bahawa beliau Dr.Jeffrey hanya berangan-angan besar seperti bermimpi disiang hari sahaja. Tetapi cuba kita lihat pemimpin-pemimpin BN sekarang Musa,Pairin dan lain-lain pemimpin BN angkat kaki, mereka sudah mula sedar dan bangun dari tidur kerana mabuk wang dan sekarang Musa,Pairin dan lain pemimpin angkat karung guni.Mereka tidak segan-segan lagi dan malu-malu untuk menyeyuarakan pendapat mereka masing-masing.Kerana apa...? mereka takut mula takut kehilangan pengaruh dan kuasa. Mereka sedar bahawa perjuangan Dr.Jeffrey adalah perjuangan RAKYAT NEGARA SABAH. Musa kata boleh dibincang dengan baik antara pemimpin Negeri dan persekutuan.Bagi saya, saya faham betul maksud dia (Musa).Budak kecil pun faham. Selama UMNO dan BN memerintah Sabah..adakah mereka ini ada bersuara tentang hak untuk negara Sabah. UMNO dan BN cuma menuntut hak peribadi sahaja. Mengumpul kekayaan keluarga.Okey, itu dari saya. Bagaimana dengan anda pula.?hsm.Sook

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Setuju dengan pendapat yang berakal fikiran

      Delete
  35. Datuk Najib Razak said the RCI to review the oil royalties will have 6 months to do so. Hopefully we can get a raise of oil royalties for Sabah and Sarawak soon.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Pihak kerajaan harus menilai keperluan untuk menambah loyalty untuk Sabah. Lihat inflasi yang semakin meningkat, kadar ini tidak mencukupi.

      Delete
  36. Ditubuhkan salah, tak ditubuhkan pun salah.. Apa lah ni...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. apa saja yang kena buat memang ada yang akan kritik.

      Delete
  37. Susah sampai masa royalti minyak dinaikkan. Saya sokong sepenuhnya dan saya harap hasilnya positif.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Logiknya pun kan zaman sekarang ni 5% tu memang tak nampak la. Jadi kerajaan pusat patut faham kalau Sabahan minta royalti dinaikkan.

    ReplyDelete
  39. Dengan perhatian dari CM dan juga para pemimpin yang lain, pasti royalti dapat dinaikkan dalam amaun yang boleh diterima.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Kalau berjaya, pasti Sabahan bahagia oo. hehehe. Semoga semuanya berjalan lancar dan janganlah terlalu demand pula nanti satu pun tak dapat, susah juga kan:P

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ya, kita semua mengharapkan yang terbaik untuk Sabah.

      Delete
  41. komitmen CM memang dialu-alukan dalam pekara ini.

    ReplyDelete
  42. keprihatian KM dalam pekara ini memang baik dan harap ianya akan memberikan hasil yang positif.

    ReplyDelete
  43. entah- entah untuk political spending? Someone just raised a point that this oil matter belongs to the rakyat. Any wheeling and dealing should involve the DUN. Not a one-man show. Did I get that right?

    ReplyDelete
  44. Iklas atau tidak itu belakang kira. apa yang penting mereka suda berjanji untuk membincangkan hal itu.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Harap mereka dapat membawa something yang dapat meredakan kemarahan rakyat.

    ReplyDelete
  46. Kerajaan akan mencari jalan agar rakyat mendapatkan apa yang inginkan.

    ReplyDelete
  47. of course la sincere.. samada sebab pilihanraya atau tidak, ada ku kesah.. yang penting masalah ini selesai.. dan tidak lama lagi pembangkang bakal kehilangan isu untuk dimain2kan masa kepen pilihanraya.. itulah sebabnya pembangkang takut bila kerajaan umumkan RCI dan kejian semula royalti minyak..

    ReplyDelete
  48. the demand of RCI and oil royalty made by opposition is sincere?? why must they questioned about it when they are also demand for it?

    ReplyDelete
  49. Hope opposition is sincere to strike the best for the people.

    ReplyDelete