Search This Blog
Sunday, July 8, 2012
Does SAPP give Dr Jeff headache?
Since leaving BN three years ago SAPP has been consistently working in KDM areas and has within its fold capable and winnable KDM leaders.
By Amde Sidik
State Reform Party (STAR) Sabah chapter chairman Dr Jeffery Kitingan has recently said that Sabah Progressive Peoples Party (SAPP) was still giving him a headache.
FMT in its article – Jeffrey’s twin ‘thorns’ – Bumburing, SAPP, published on July 5 – quoted him as saying “It’s SAPP that bothers me…”
As a deputy president of SAPP, I am not sure how to respond to his statement.
Usually SAPP leaders would just keep quiet, but I feel this time I should respectfully state our stand.
I don’t exactly know what Jeffery means when he said we are a ‘headache’ because when we met a couple of weeks ago everything was all right.
We, in SAPP, do not change our mind for the sake of changing, because it could confuse people.
We have been consistent in our stand and have time and again reiterated the same thing.
Three years ago we made known to the public our eight points declarations and now we have a comprehensive party manifesto, with extensive descriptions on economic and land matters.
So far SAPP’s leaders are quite coherent and tactfully consistent in handling sticky issues which is likely to cause uneasiness among fellow oppositions.
For SAPP nothing is more important than sticking together, not just within the party but also all among opposition parties in Sabah.
This is because we believe the work to defeat Barisan Nasional (BN) is so great a task. We therefore cannot afford to waste our energy and time unnecessarily.
But sometimes being tactful could also lead to all kind of interpretations such as us being construed as arrogant, uncooperative, greedy and so forth.
Untouchable KDM areas?
To be frank, SAPP (bumiputera) leaders are too preoccupied with their work on the ground and this is one of reasons why they could not care less what others are saying.
Which brings me to Jeffrey’s statement about SAPP encroaching into KDM areas.
To me this sounds a bit odd if not old fashion. Are (KDM-turfs) really that divided? Are we (KDM areas) now a kind of untouchable territory?
Have we not had enough of what Umno (and its divisive policies) has done to us?
SAPP would contest in places where it is prepared. And a reminder to Jeffrey, SAPP wasn’t born three months ago.
SAPP members have been working on ground zero tirelessly for the last three years. It was hard work at the beginning, but we see the fruit of our labour now.
Of course, many of our leaders are not in the media limelight and 80% of our activities never get reported, especially those in the interior and rural kampungs.
But that did not bother us before, and it still does not bother us now. SAPP has been working to prepare for general election since three years ago.
In fact we’ve been working in these areas since SAPP got out of BN and and the idea behind this was to avoid the need for people to parachute in at the last hour to become candidates.
A great many SAPP members are party workers who have no intention of becoming candidates.
They work as hard as the leaders and we have them all over Sabah – in urban, semi urban and in rural kampungs.
And this is what we in SAPP think we really are – we are propagating non-racial politics.
‘We have KDM leaders’
Of course for all intent and practical purposes it may not work 100% today and this is due to many reasons, one of which is the stereotyped idea engrained in our old leaders’ mentality.
But if we do not attempt to change this thinking today, we will never start anyway.
In short, if SAPP is contesting in KDM areas, it is because SAPP has KDM leaders in those areas.
I do not think there is such a thing as territory exclusiveness belonging to a particular political party.
I would like to make it absolutely clear here that we are friends to all opposition but Umno (Anything But Umno – ABU)
Amde Sidik is the deputy president of Sabah Progressive Peoples Party (SAPP)
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I would suggest that STAR can only put their candidates in DUN Tambunan & Bingkor as well as the Parliment seats in which they feel winable area, if there are really wants to voice out for Sabahan rights. My points of view, SAPP has really committed in Liawan, Sook, Tenom, Ranau and some of the others area that i haven't mentions.
ReplyDeleteBro, you must be kidding that Sapp is stronger than Star in Liawan, Sook, Tenom and Ranau. Turun padang and you will be surprised at Star's strength. Even old Usno is stronger than Sapp in Tenom and the strength of Sapp in Tenom also depends on who is their candidate.
DeleteSAPP lemah...tidak akan menang...mungkin akan hilang deposit juga..
DeleteSAPP dan STAR, dua2 tidak akan menang, hilang deposit juga.
DeleteKDM areas that STAR is strong does not mean that STAR is racial.
ReplyDeleteIt cannot be denied that STAR is strong is the KDM areas and it is stronger than SAPP in many non-KDM areas except that Sapp does not wish to acknowledge so.
The strength of Sapp during BN times, during UBF without Star and after Star has launched in January 2012, are different except some people do not wish to accept such a reality. Sapp today is still thinking that its strength today is during its BN times which includes support of other BN component parties. In reality, it is not as strong today as it was during BN times and during the times Star was not present in Sabah.
Similarly, it cannot be denied that Sapp is perceived to be a Chinese-based party. Look at their line-up and focused areas. It cannot also be denied that Dap is stronger than Sapp in many Chinese areas.
Sapp can only lose its tag as a Chinese party if its leader is a non-Chinese. Can this be done?
Whether the perception is important to certain people or not, the overriding factor is to win the election. It is no use to pursue with the perception so that all Opposition parties will go for the same seats because of their perception that their party is better than the other, then at the of the day it is the BN which will win the seats. Then, what will the Opposition get? Nothing but their PERCEPTIONS!!!!
DeleteSAPP lemah...mungkin lebih lemah daripada Star...
DeleteKekalahan di Batu Sapi belum cukup lagi ka?
DeleteSAPP mmg lemah. tgk YTL pun boleh kalah teruk di Batu Sapi.
DeleteYTL tidka akan mendapat sambutan hangat oleh golongan awam, banyak agak kecewa dengan pimpinan beliau.
DeleteSapp n star same only ..... Greedy want the opposition vote for themselves by putting a fence of not working with PR. don't b so arrogant la .... work with PR la..... share your synergy la
ReplyDeletePR buat kacau saja di sabah...lebih baik PR hanya bertapak di semenanjung...PR juga ingin 'menjajah' sabah...
DeletePR patut bagi laluan sama parti local di Sabah. Ini tidak..mahu juga menyibuk. Jangan tamak la.
Deletemungkin perlu ada limit untuk penubuhan parti di Sabah ni. makin lama makin banyak pula.
Deletesibuk berebut kawasan antara SAPP dan Star...last2 dua2 pun kalah..
ReplyDeletedi ampung-kampung star lebih diterima daripada sapp. Itulah pemerhatian jujur.
Deletemerekac berebut.. BN akan dpt manfaat.
DeleteBN masih menjadi pilihan rakyat, SAPP dan Star tolak tepi, tidak membawa apa2 perubahan kepada Sabah.
DeleteMemang tiada kesatuan ni. tidak hairan dua2 pun kalah.
Deletemasing-masing tidak mahu mengalah..inilah jadinya.
DeleteSTAR and SAPP can't get along? Bad sign.
ReplyDeleteunity and teamwork will ensure a great win for BN so it could remain as the ruling party.
DeleteParty members who are highly united will be the key factor in determining victory for BN in the next general election
ReplyDeleteBukan sahaja Batu Sapi.
ReplyDeleteBukan sahaja Sapp tidak diterima KDM.
KDM maseh belum lupa pengkhianatan YTL terhadap Huguan dan PBS dulu.
SAPP ingat rakyat akan diperbodohkan sekali lagi, tidak mungkin. Undi SAPP, sekali dah cukup, tidak perlu kita terpedaya kali kedua.
DeleteKDM berapa ekor saja di Malaysia....sekrangpun sudah number tiga....apa ego sangat kot....nanti habis PRU13 jadi gelap gulita. Fikirkan lah....
ReplyDeleteStar won't go far because they don't have enough strong supporter from people.
ReplyDeleteBro,
DeleteTurun padang lihat sendiri sokongan Star.
JK tidak hadir pun ramai yang hadir.
Kamu sebagai penyokong Sapp, ceklah betul2.
Banyak kali kamurang punya boss turun padang pun tidak ramai hadir.
Kalau sebut nama kampung, nanti malu lagi.
Yang sokong Star dan Sapp tu suku sakat durang juga..
DeleteTidak payah turun padang, selepas PRU-13 diadakan, kita tengok berapa undi Star dapat berbanding parti lain. Cukup jelas pilihan rakyat menerusi undian.
DeleteTunggu saja hasilnya lepas PRU.
DeleteSAPP sudah kalah di Batu Sapi..itu tak cukup lagi kh?
ReplyDeleteJadikan isu pilihanraya Batu Sapi sebagai pengajaran. PKR sudah minta SAPP bagi laluan masa itu, tapi SAPP dengan ego mereka enggan memberi jalan. Akhirnya dua-dua parti pembangkang kalah.
DeleteTahniah kepada Datin Linda Tsen, rakyat Sandakan membuat pilihan yang bernas.
Kerjasama dari semua pemimpin BN pasti akan membawa lagi kemenangan yang besar.
ReplyDeleteTiada konflik dalam BN bukan seperti Pembangkang yang sering berlawan terutamanya sudah dekat PRU-13. Nampaknya BN akan menang lagi PRU-13, Hidup BN.
DeleteParti komponen harus bersefahaman memperjuangkan agenda yang sama.
DeleteSAPP dan Star tetap berlawan sesama diri walaupun sering berkata nak bekerjasama. Susah untuk dua parti ini bersatu jika masing-masing mahukan kuasa untuk diri sendiri.
ReplyDeleteMasing-masing ada agenda sendiri, bukan mudah untuk bekerjasama.
DeletePembangkang harus mencari formula untuk bekerjasama.
ReplyDeletekalau masing-masing mau jadi hero susah untuk bekerjasama.
DeleteLet see how far STAR can go as a new parti in Sabah.
ReplyDeleteJeffrey yang membuat SAPP binggung sekarang ini. Sehinggakan SAPP terpaksa berkerjasama dengan PR.
ReplyDeletejadi susah jugalah mau berlaku formula 1 lawan 1 ni kan.
Deletekalau ini berterusan sapp dan star lagi yang tidak akan ngam.
ReplyDeleteini menunjukkan sapp dan star susah untuk bekerjasama.
ReplyDeleteKesian kalau kita lihat mengenai isu yang berkaitan dengan SAPP dan STAR ini.
ReplyDeleteApa yang ada dengan SAPP sebenarnya?? Cuma PR saja yang tersuka dengan SAPP ini kerana PR risau tidak mendapat sokongan daripada rakyat.
ReplyDeletePRU mau dekat sudah.. alang2 kasi iktiraf lawan saja la.. bukan tidak pernah pembangkang sama pembangkang lawan sesama sendiri..
ReplyDeleteSTAR ni pun satu.. nampak betul dia punya tamaha.. sedangkan parti itu hanya parti reject dari Sarawak..
ReplyDeleteAs BN is getting motivated waiting for the coming election, opposition parties especially PKR seemed anxious. Their anxiety are getting more when their own Opposition Leader, Anwar Ibrahim stated that he would retire if they lose in the coming GE, like what was published by newspaper Financial Times (FT). How can PKR hope for a win if the suitable candidate are hard to find?
ReplyDeleteBased on sources afloat in in various blog in the internet, PKR would compete for 66 seats for the coming GE13. On the previous GE 2008, PKR managed to win 31 seats and gained multiple Malay votes.But, it seems that PKR's liberal approach is now causing trouble to the party in gaining votes from the Malays.
ReplyDeleteMeanwhile, Chinese are more comfortable with DAP than PKR. As for the Indians, many are tired of being cheated with false hopes given by PKR. Thus, whether they like it or not, PKR would have to rely on votes from the Chinese for the GE13.
ReplyDeleteThe same source mentioned that from 66 seats which they would compete, only 14 are from Malay candidates while 8 other candidates are from other races, which can be confirmed. 25 other seats are still in dilemma on which candidates should be in it. At least 5 seats suffered clash between PAS and DAP.
ReplyDeleteAt the same time, PKR do not even have any 'candidate of choice' either 'possible candidates' for 19 other seats. This means that from 66 seats, only 22 can be confirmed while 44 others are still undecided. This shows how hard it is for PKR to find suitable candidates, not even to find those who are fit to win in facing the coming election.
ReplyDeleteWhat is worse is that even Anwar is said to be under dilemma whether to compete in Permatang Pauh or Nibong Tebal. Anwar is said to have realized that the support among Permatang Pauh to him is declining that they would not really come to his program (ceramah) anymore.
ReplyDeleteWith such weak Leader, PAS and DAP are also dragged into the issue. PAS previously imagined that they would compete with 80 seats instead of 67 seats on the previous GE. But, the hope of PAS in wanting to be the dominant party in Pakatan Rakyat Cabinet would definitely get sour welcome from DAP and PKR.
ReplyDeleteAnd as usual, PAS would have to listen to whatever decision that are made by DAP and PKR. If this happens, DAP then would become the dominant party with 89 seats for its party, compared to PKR's 66 seats.
ReplyDeleteThis means that it would be easier for DAP to control and destroy rakyat if Pakatan Rakyat win the next GE. The fate of non-Chinese in Malaysia would be at risk if the country is under the leadership of DAP. So, this scenario shows that this would be the brink of losing for Pakatan Rakyat.
ReplyDelete