Search This Blog

Thursday, January 3, 2013

RM900 has less ‘buying power’ than in 1997

Toffee Rozario

The new minimum wage policy at RM900 for workers in Peninsular Malaysia and RM800 in Sabah and Sarawak is an insult to the worker.

On Jan 1, 2013, the minimum wage policy came into effect. It’s still a contensious issue although the Human Resources Minister says less than 700 employers had requested for deferments.

Truth is the new minimum wage policy at RM900 for workers in Peninsular Malaysia and RM800 for those in Sabah and Sarawak is an insult to the worker.

The Malaysian worker has not recovered since the 1997 Asian financial crisis. Had he recovered, his wages could have grown in terms of ringgit received.

Today if you equate his earnings with its buying power, the Malaysian worker is earning far less than he did pre-1997.

As such, the new minimum wage at RM900 for workers in Peninsular Malaysia and RM800 in Sabah and Sarawak is meaningless.

Take a look at the increases in the prices of houses, rice, petrol, sugar, education, toll and interest rates for loans. See how poor this worker has become.

Thus the RM900 a month is an insult to the worker.

The RM900 proposal was actually mooted by the Malaysian Trade Union Congress (MTUC) prior to 1997. In fact in 1992, MTUC was seeking minimum salary to be fixed at RM1,200 but had indicated it would settle for RM900.

But the government led by Dr Mahathir Mohamad would not have it.

To do so would attract too many Malaysians to factories and that would put a dent to the influx of foreign labour which had become a good source of income for many government officials, including some ministers at that time.

The Human Resources Ministry was then propagating a performance-driven wage system, but that too did not work out when it brought in cheap foreign labour. These workers were also grossly exploited, thus lowering wages.

So MTUC’s rightful request for better wages was stamped out.

Corruption negates productivity

Now the government is using this lowered wage as the benchmark in industry to tell the Malaysian worker who had reached peak productive performance, to improve his performance; what an extremely wicked scheme.

Once the human effort has been exploited to its maximum, productivity increase can only come about with the introduction of more modern methods and that is the domain of management.

Yet take a look at the wage disparity between the workforce and the management which is unable to provide this advantage to the worker who has already peaked.

We still tap rubber the same way HN Ridley did when he first brought rubber to this country and even if there had been any improvement, it is totally insignificant. We harvest oil palm fruits the way it was done in the early 1950s, and what has this government done to improve that?

History notes that the Malaysian worker is the most productive in the world and yet today the wages that the Malaysian worker receive is no reflection of his/her productive efforts.

This is because any fool will tell you that when you have rampant corruption in a country, no matter how hard and skilfull the best workers produce goods of high quality and at the lowest cost, the result of their efforts will remain unproductive.

In short, corruption negates productivity.

The country which once had the most productive workforce now suffers because we are fast becoming a rogue nation, with huge surplus of corrupt government ministers and officials.

Back in the 1970s right to the early 1980s, the Malaysian workers were paid more than their Korean counterparts and more than the Taiwanese. In the early to mid-1960s, we were paid more than the Singaporeans.

So what happened? Why is it today our salaries are lagging far behind the workers in these countries?

No one seems to ask and no one seems to even worry except the Malaysian worker who has to live with a meagre RM900.

Mahathir afraid

In 1997, the exchange rate of the ringgit to the American dollar was one US dollar to about RM2.90; with the 1997 crisis, it went to one US dollar to RM3.50, and in that one episode alone the Malaysian worker had his salary slashed by a hefty 20%.

This was something the worker had not really realised and neither did Mahathir, the then prime minister, reveal to the Malaysian worker.

This is because even as Mahathir blamed George Soros for the currency crisis, Soros was doing a good job exposing Mahathir. Mahathir was afraid of being exposed to an angry Malaysian workforce.

Now Malaysian productivity is low, so low because Malaysians just do not have the motivation anymore to work.

And all this is a direct result of the policies of the Barisan Nasional government.

The more you make, the more they (BN government) take.

54 comments:

  1. The minimum wage for the private sector between RM800 and RM900 per month was in the interests of the employer and the employee, said Deputy Finance Minister Datuk Dr Awang Adek Hussin

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Polisi ini akan membebankan pemilik perniagaan jenis kecil kecilan.

      Delete
    2. Tapi ini usaha kerajaan untuk menetapkan gaji minimum.

      Delete
    3. Bagus lagi BN daripada janji PR bagi RM1,100 untuk gaji minimum.

      Delete
    4. Memang teruk perniaga kecil kalau PR yang mentadbir.

      Delete
    5. kerajaan telah cuba yang terbaik untuk membantu mengurangkan beban yang dihadapi oleh rakyat.

      Delete
    6. Kita tahu yang mana pembangkang telah cuba memutarbelitkan mengenai gaji minimum ini.

      Delete
    7. Polisi ini seakan menambah lagi beban rakyat untuk menampung kos harian yang lebih tinggi.

      Delete
    8. Adakah kamurang tidak setuju denga polis gaji minimum untuk memberikan gaji yang berpatutan kepada para pekerja?

      Delete
  2. He said the government had considered the interest of both the employers and employees before deciding on the wages.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Such policy needed to execute stage after stage.

      Delete
    2. Setuju dengan anonymous, harus dilaksanakan secara berperingkat agar tanggungan majikan dapat diseimbangkan.

      Delete
    3. Harap-harap semua orang dapat menerima baik keputusan melaksanakan polisi gaji minima ini.

      Delete
  3. “All of our policies must have beneficial impact in the long term and not be driven by a short term consideration,” he told reporters after launching a marathon in conjunction with Umno’s 66th anniversary celebration here

    ReplyDelete
  4. Awang Adek was asked to comment on MTUC’s statement that the newly set minimum wage was insufficient for those living in the cities.

    ReplyDelete
  5. It was reported that the RM900 or RM4.33 per hour is for employees in the peninsula while the RM800 or RM3.85 per hour is for workers in Sarawak, Sabah and the Federal Territory of Labuan.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Untuk golongan yang berpendapatan rendah adalah berita baik, tetapi apa gunanya jika lepas ini pendapatan ini menampung kos perbelanjaan yang lebih tinggi?

      Delete
    2. At least the government is doing something for the people that under pay.

      Delete
  6. He said if the gvernment had set at the rate between RM1,200 and RM1,500, it would scare away investors who were looking for cheap labour in the country.

    ReplyDelete
  7. “If they decide to invest in other countries such as China and Vietnam, our country will lose out and there will be less job opportunities for the locals,” he said.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Banyak yang akan kehilangan kerja lepas ini.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jika majikan tidak dapat menampung kos yang tinggi, akan juga memecat pekerja untuk mengawal kos masing-masing. Yang merisikokan masih rakyat sendiri.

      Delete
  9. Lepas ini pasti banyak impak di pasaran khas barangan yang lebih mahal.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. harga barangan haruslah dikawal.

      Delete
    2. Jika kerajaan gagal mengawal kenaikan harga barangan, tetap masih berada kepada rakyat sendiri.

      Delete
  10. jika tiada upah minimum, ramai pekerja akan ditindas dgn mendapat upah terlalu sedikit.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Kajian Guna Tenaga Kebangsaan (NER) oleh Kementerian Sumber Manusia pada 2009 mendapati bahawa 33.8% pekerja bergaji di bawah RM700 sebulan yakni di bawah paras kemiskinan kebangsaan, RM800 sebulan pada masa ini.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Kajian oleh Bank Dunia pula menunjukkan bahawa sejak 10 tahun yang lepas, kadar gaji di Malaysia hanya meningkat secara purata sebanyak 2.6% setahun, walaupun kadar produktiviti buruh (real labour productivity) meningkat sebanyak 6.7% setahun.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Ini menunjukkan bahawa terdapat herotan (distortion) dalam pasaran buruh yang mengekang peningkatan kadar gaji sedangkan produktiviti dan kos sara hidup meningkat dengan cepat.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Kerajaan akan meneliti semua usaha ini. Jangan risau. Kerajaan akan buat yang terbaik.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Kadar gaji minimum bagi Semenanjung Malaysia ditetapkan pada kadar RM900 sebulan atau RM4.33 sejam, sementara bagi Sarawak, Sabah dan Wilayah Persekutuan Labuan sebanyak RM800 sebulan atau RM3.85 sejam

    ReplyDelete
  16. Selepas mempertimbangkan pandangan Majlis Perundingan Gaji Negara (MPGN) yang mewaili sebahagian besar majikan serta kakitangan di Sabah dan pakar ekonomi termasuk daripada Bank Dunia, kadar RM800 ditetapkan sebagai gaji minima di Sabah.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Seperti dijangka, pembangkang pantas menjadikan isu ini sebagai modal politik. Mereka megkritik kadar gaji minima itu sebagai terlalu rendah, selain menganggapnya tidak adil berikutan kadar berbeza yang ditetapkan di Semenanjung.

      Delete
  17. gaji minima bukannya tongkat sakti untuk menyelesaikan segala masalah ekonomi dan cabaran yang dihadapi kakitangan berpendapatan rendah.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kerajaan mempunyai pelbagai kaedah lain dalam membantu mereka, termasuk subsidi mencecah berbilion ringgit, pemberian tunai dan kursus latihan bagi meningkatkan kemahiran masing-masing.

      Delete
  18. Gaji minimum bukan bertujuan mengubah status golongan berpendapatan rendah kepada kumpulan berpendapatan tinggi.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Gaji minima lebih menjurus kepada penanda aras asas supaya gaji ditawarkan tidak kurang daripada kadar ditetapkan kerajaan.

      Delete
    2. Majikan boleh menawarkan gaji lebih tinggi jika berasa pekerja layak menerimanya berdasarkan kelayakan dan kemahiran.

      Delete
    3. Hope that the minimum wage policy can ensure fair wages for all employees.

      Delete
  19. Ada perbezaan besar pendekatan antara Barisan Nasional dan Pakatan Rakyat dalam isu ini.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Pakatan Rakyat melihatnya dari pandangan populis dan oleh sebab itu hanya berminat untuk melihatnya dari pespektif pekerja semata-mata (tidak menghairankan kerana pekerja merupakan pengundi teramai). Berbeza dengan kerajaan yang perlu berlaku adil dan bertanggungjawab kepada semua pihak.

      Delete
    2. pasti pendekatan kerajaan akan dapat membantu semua pihak yang terlibat dalam minimum wage itu.

      Delete
    3. We'll see for ourselves whose approach is better received by the people.

      Delete
  20. The thing is, the disparity of prices of goods are obvious.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Let's hope the disparity of prices will be controlled by the government.

      Delete
  21. Apa pun harus selaraskan gaji itu.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Sabah should get RM1000 per month.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Gaji minimum Sabah harus lebih tinggi dari itu.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Sabahans deserve to get more than that.

    ReplyDelete