KOTA KINABALU: Industrial Development Minister Datuk Raymond Tan Shu Kiah has mistaken the hard truth for "rudeness and unfriendly" when responding to the criticisms by his Barisan Nasional (BN) colleagues that his party, Gerakan is irrelevant and should not field candidates in Sabah.
Sabah Progressive Party (SAPP) Information Chief, Chong Pit Fah said in fact Tan and Elopura Assemblyman, Au Kam Wah, who had joined Gerakan after leaving SAPP when it ditched the BN on Sept 17, 2008, had lost the respect of their BN colleagues.
Sabah Progressive Party (SAPP) Information Chief, Chong Pit Fah said in fact Tan and Elopura Assemblyman, Au Kam Wah, who had joined Gerakan after leaving SAPP when it ditched the BN on Sept 17, 2008, had lost the respect of their BN colleagues.
"Now that Raymond Tan and Au Kam Wah have lost face and the respect of their BN colleagues, the only honourable thing for them to do is to resign all their government posts immediately," Chong said in a statement here Tuesday.
Tan was also a Deputy Chief Minister when he was the deputy president of SAPP prior to the Sept 17, 2008 SAPP exodus from BN, while Au was the Youth Chief of SAPP.
Both, however, disagreed with the SAPP leadership's decision to leave the ruling BN government after these two failed to take note of the "window of opportunity" that SAPP believed would address pertinent issues affecting Sabah.
After several months in political wilderness, Tan and Au decided to join Gerakan, gifting the peninsular-based party, two state seats in the process.
Tan was appointed as one of the vice presidents later.
Gerakan was "gifted" its third state seat when Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) former vice president, Datuk Peter Pang, who was then also a Deputy Chief Minister (replacing Tan), left his party after disagreeing with the stand opposing the present Chief Minister Datuk Seri Musa Aman.
The prospect of Gerakan being given the three seats and contest in the coming General Election had received negative feedback from within the BN itself.
It began with Umno MP for Kalabakan, Datuk Abdul Ghapur Salleh who during his Budget Debate speech urged the Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak to consider against fielding any candidate from Gerakan in the coming election.
He said it had been proven in the last election that Gerakan had been rejected by the people in Semenanjung and what more in Sabah, should it contest in the state in the 13th General Election.
His sentiment was shared by former Libaran MP Akbar Khan Abdul Rahman who said the State BN leadership must consider Ghapur's view because it came from the grassroots.
Later, LDP joined in the bandwagon saying that "although the truth might be bitter" but the leadership must consider that winnable candidate must come from a winnable political party.
Other BN leaders like Umno supreme council member, Datuk Lajim Ukin and Parti Bersatu Rakyat Sabah (PBRS) President Tan Sri Joseph Kurup echoed similar view and said that there were already too many political parties in Sabah and that Gerakan should instead concentrate on getting their seats back in the Peninsular Malaysia.
Tan speaking for the first time on the matter had called the BN component leaders "to stop the harsh words being used against his party".
He was reported as saying that he declined to be engaged in the debate on the issue and preferred to raise it during the BN meeting but that he was concerned about the image of Gerakan.
"Sabah Gerakan had already shown that it has good leaders. We are just asking for the opportunity like any other BN component party to contest in order to defend BN in Sabah," said Tan.
Tan continued to be a State Cabinet member and but had to relinquish his Deputy Chief Minister post (for the Chinese quota) when he joined Gerakan.
Now that they have lost face, Chong said Tan must resign from his Cabinet post as well as the KKIP chairmanship, so as Au who had been appointed as the Chairman of the Sabah Energy Corporation.
Gerakan was "gifted" its third state seat when Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) former vice president, Datuk Peter Pang, who was then also a Deputy Chief Minister (replacing Tan), left his party after disagreeing with the stand opposing the present Chief Minister Datuk Seri Musa Aman.
The prospect of Gerakan being given the three seats and contest in the coming General Election had received negative feedback from within the BN itself.
It began with Umno MP for Kalabakan, Datuk Abdul Ghapur Salleh who during his Budget Debate speech urged the Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak to consider against fielding any candidate from Gerakan in the coming election.
He said it had been proven in the last election that Gerakan had been rejected by the people in Semenanjung and what more in Sabah, should it contest in the state in the 13th General Election.
His sentiment was shared by former Libaran MP Akbar Khan Abdul Rahman who said the State BN leadership must consider Ghapur's view because it came from the grassroots.
Later, LDP joined in the bandwagon saying that "although the truth might be bitter" but the leadership must consider that winnable candidate must come from a winnable political party.
Other BN leaders like Umno supreme council member, Datuk Lajim Ukin and Parti Bersatu Rakyat Sabah (PBRS) President Tan Sri Joseph Kurup echoed similar view and said that there were already too many political parties in Sabah and that Gerakan should instead concentrate on getting their seats back in the Peninsular Malaysia.
Tan speaking for the first time on the matter had called the BN component leaders "to stop the harsh words being used against his party".
He was reported as saying that he declined to be engaged in the debate on the issue and preferred to raise it during the BN meeting but that he was concerned about the image of Gerakan.
"Sabah Gerakan had already shown that it has good leaders. We are just asking for the opportunity like any other BN component party to contest in order to defend BN in Sabah," said Tan.
Tan continued to be a State Cabinet member and but had to relinquish his Deputy Chief Minister post (for the Chinese quota) when he joined Gerakan.
Now that they have lost face, Chong said Tan must resign from his Cabinet post as well as the KKIP chairmanship, so as Au who had been appointed as the Chairman of the Sabah Energy Corporation.
Biarlah parti Gerakan yang menentukan sama ada mereka berdua ini patut letak jawatan ataupun tidak.
ReplyDeletemereka kena buktikan yang mereka masih releven untuk Gerakan.
ReplyDeleteapapun, biarlah mereka selesaikan hal ini.
ReplyDeleteit's up to them la mau resign ka tidak.. tidak perlu ada suara2 sumbang dari luar minta mereka resign..
ReplyDeleteNever ending speculation on the coming election.
ReplyDeleteLets the people decide and start focusing how to serve the people
Gerakan tidak relevan di sabah...BN sabah mampu mentadbir kerajaan negeri dan menang pada PRU akan datang tanpa Gerakan yang cuba mencari 'suaka politik' di sabah disebabkan telah kalah pada PRU12 di penang.
ReplyDeletependirian pemimpin sabah harus diterima oleh presiden Gerakan...Gerakan seharusnya fokus di semenanjung khasnya di penang untuk kekal relevan dalam politik malaysia.
ReplyDeleteyang pasti Gerakan akan menjadi liabiliti kepada BN sabah pada PRU akan datang..
ReplyDeletekeputusan ditangan mereka...
ReplyDeleteharap mereka dapat menyelesaian kan masalah ini...
ReplyDeleteWell honestly, Gerakan is not relevant. Why come to sabah when they can't get the people support in their own place.
ReplyDeleteWat is this about asking tan and au to resign immediately..??its their decision to make if they want to quit
ReplyDeleteSelesaikanlah masalah parti dengan cara baik. Jangan sampai masalah yang melanda menimbulkan perspektif -ve.
ReplyDeleteSoal resign tu terpulanglah pada Tan dan Au. Kita lihat sajalah apa yang berlaku nanti:)
ReplyDeleteisu macam ni lebih mencari kesepakatan terbaik melalui perbincangan..
ReplyDeleteapa pun, biarlah isu ini diselesaikan dengan sebaiknya atas semangat kekeluargaan.
ReplyDeletelebih baik berbincang di meja rundingan daripada terus melontarkan pandangan2 negatif. lagipun mereka 1 komponen juga kan. bersikaplah lebih profesional.
ReplyDeleteIt is up to Tan and Au whether they want to resign or not.
ReplyDeleteIf they want to compete, just let them compete. Its the people who will decide their fate in the end.
ReplyDeleteMasalah gerakan mahu duduk kerusi di Sabah mungkin perlulah dikaji dan dibincangkan antara parti komponen.
ReplyDeleteNeed discussion with all party members..Gerakan should concentrate in PP better than Sabah.
ReplyDeleteGerakan has to be realistic if they want to contest in Sabah or not. And it's up to Tan and Au to resign or not..
ReplyDeleteToo many parties in Sabah. Gerakan has little chance or maybe none at all.
ReplyDelete"Tan and Au decided to join Gerakan, gifting the peninsular-based party, two state seats in the process. Tan was appointed as one of the vice presidents later."
ReplyDeleteIm sure Tan & Au will make a good decision to join Gerakan. Hope such decision turn up good to Gerakan in Sabah.
May be it is not a right time for Gerakan to come to Sabah. Gerakan failure in Penang give negative perception to the people in Sabah.
ReplyDeleteGerakan kehilangan identitinya selepas hilang kuasa di Penang. Kini, keputusan mencuba di Sabah berkemungkinan satu tindakan yang kurang bijak. Walaubagaimanapun, jika berikhlas untuk berkhidmat untuk rakyat, tetap rakyat akan memberi peluang.
ReplyDeleteParti komponen BN puin tidak memberi sokongan dan galakan, susah untuk rakyat beryakin dengan Gerakan. Gerakan harus membuktikan kebolehan dan keupayaannya untuk membawa perubahan kepada ekonomi di Sabah.
ReplyDelete"Sabah Gerakan had already shown that it has good leaders. We are just asking for the opportunity like any other BN component party to contest in order to defend BN in Sabah," said Tan.
ReplyDeleteTidak salah untuk Gerakan mencuba. Kekalahan harus diterima juga jika keputusan tidak dalam jangkaan.
Don't spoil ties over seats!! urged the CM.
ReplyDeleteStop bickering !! the matter should be discused later and in a more appropriate manner
Ini lar dunia politik yang tidak dapat terima walaupun masalah remeh-temeh. Semoga semua pertelingkahan dan salah faham diantaranya dapat dibawa bincang dan mencari cara penyelesaiannya.
ReplyDeleteMasalah parti komponen harus dibincang dan diselesaikan dengan bijak & matang. Perselisihan faham sebegini cuma memberi kesan negatif sahaja.
ReplyDelete"Sabah Gerakan had already shown that it has good leaders. We are just asking for the opportunity like any other BN component party to contest in order to defend BN in Sabah,"
ReplyDeleteParti komponen tidak memberi peluang, cam mana rakyat memberi peluang?
Gerakan digalakkan memperbaiki kedudukannya di Semenanjung khasnya Penang. Apakah sebab orang Penang menolak Gerakan? Adakah Orang Sabahan akan menerimanya? Memang agak susah sebenarnya.
ReplyDelete"Datuk Abdul Ghapur Salleh who during his Budget Debate speech urged the Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak to consider against fielding any candidate from Gerakan in the coming election."
ReplyDeleteAwait for najib new formula about the seats delegation. Im sure Najib could propose brilliant idea to resolve Gerakan issue.
In politics once you lost your bargain power or not in control you shall see the real face of many typical 'UMNOnian' to dump you.
ReplyDeleteAlways believe these men need a lesson from those Gerakan,MCA,MIC Ex-Presidents or even local Sabah Ex-parties or LDP Ex-Prez!
Look at many Ex- Tun and Tan Sri or Datuk Seri
sometimes men become forgetful or blind!
If you don't change they are going to change you for sure.
Again, cut the crap.
ReplyDeleteKalau ada masalah dalam parti, buat la perhimpunan ke apa.
ReplyDeleteCome on la SAPP, don't you have better things to do?
ReplyDeleteCukup la dengan pertempuran kamurang ni.
ReplyDeleteWhatever.
ReplyDelete