Oh boy, here we go again with misguided concepts about patriotism! Datuk Yahya Hussein this week had accused the opposition for being unpatriotic following criticism of the state budget by DAP’s Jimmy Wong, Sri Tanjung’s opposition Assemblyman. Yahya took the opportunity to blurt out such extreme comments against him as, “To the opposition like … Jimmy Wong, the budget today is meaningless … no matter how much the budget is it is incorrect… it is opposed in a way that is membabi buta (blindly)… when the opposition talks about Sabah, everything about it is bad but when they talk about other states such as Penang and Selangor, it is all good.”
“People like these are unpatriotic. I hope the people would be aware of the opposition’s habit and objectives because they only aim to rule but do not know what to do if they achieve it. They should not be given any chance to rule the State because it would be like releasing a dog from captivity.”
My first impression of this outburst is that one state BN leader has lost his cool in dealing with the opposition in the august house. Yahya lost his own dignity as a senior leader by making such childish remarks. He clearly believes that the opposition leaders are a bunch of idiots who are talking blindly (like pigs?), and totally unfit to rule the state, i.e. they wouldn’t know how to rule and they will behave like ungrateful dogs! Two derogatory references to dirty animals (pigs and dogs) are mentioned by Yahya which was a strong hint at equating them to poor Jimmy.
But never mind that, because people call each other by animal names all the time, e.g. pig, dog, monkey, snake, serpent, fox, flying fox, chicken, buffalo and so on. But what irks me most is that the BN leaders have gone into the bad habit of calling leaders of the opposition as being unpatriotic. Those who criticize the BN government abroad are branded as smearing the name of the country, even trying to destroy the country. As I remember, Tengku Razaleigh Hamzah was the first to be accused of doing this when he revealed the corruption of the BN under Umno, who as Ku Li put it, “awarded projects to themselves.” It didn’t matter that what he said was true; he was highly demonized as unpatriotic and anti-national. Thereafter if was Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, Nurul Izzah, Raja Petra Kamaruddin and others. One minister recently accused the Indians and Chinese unpatriotic for not being interested in joining the security forces. It later turned out to be a terrible blunder for which the minister had to publicly apologize. Now it is Jimmy Wong who is an unpatriotic political animal for criticizing the state budget!
But I would like to confront Yahya and ask him point blank: How patriotic do you think the BN/Umno leaders are towards Sabah? I think it is the 14th year that we have been having a deficit budget. How come we never know how much of the budget allocation had been spent every year? How much of the new budget is carry-forward amounts for delayed projects?
How patriotic are those leaders who go overseas to purchase expensive handbags, multimillion-dollar rings, or makes purchases of submarines, military helicopters and whatnots and try to get hundreds of millions in kickbacks? How patriotic is Umno Sabah for taking all the top posts of the Sabah BN Committee, for ignoring the people’s endless calls for an RCI on the illegal immigrants? Where was the patriotism of Umno when it set into motion a secret program to legalize illegal immigrants by giving the MyKads overnight in what is now famously called “Projek IC”? How patriotic is Umno Sabah for supporting the cabotage policy which for years have been causing the high inflation in Sabah, hence killing the consumers in the state, while it continues to pretend not to hear all the many years of protests against it? What about the unending grabs of NCR lands against natives by big companies and with no intervention from Umno leaders?
And what wonderful patriotism Umno Sabah can talk about when it ignores the call for a White Paper on the huge, huge, unconscionable Saham Amanah (SAS) scandal?
And if Umno is such a great planner in reviving the economy of the state, why did Sabah become the poorest state beginning with Umno’s the takeover of the state in 1994? Why has one company connected to a senior BN leader taken most of the road building projects in Sabah? And why are the people complaining about construction projects being usually overpriced by up to 100% their actual costs? Hey, I can go on a whole day with these questions….
I have said it before that the opposition leaders are not idiots who simply fire at the BN membabi buta, but we watch whatever the BN is doing with the sharp eyes of the hawk. We are the sober ones because we are not the ones drunk with power and corruption! We are fighting the abuses power by the BN because we love our state, because we want to defend the people of Sabah from the clever political manipulations, to reverse the negative trends which are slowly killing the state.
As for Penang and Selangor, they have made tremendous progress in improving the governance of these states. Even the Auditor General made a glowing commentary on the transparent and effective leadership of Penang by Lim Guan Eng who by the way, doesn’t have a mansion and travels on planes by economy class on! Here its proven that the opposition leaders and governments are very, very patriotic indeed, unlike some leaders who are behaving like robbers who bring down their own states with their misdeeds.
DANIEL JOHN JAMBUN
Sometimes tempers flares uncontrollably and emotions are difficult to check when you are in anger.Words that you don't really mean to say spilled out unwittingly only to realise later that you shouldn't be saying something that you really don't mean at all.
ReplyDeleteI agree that as a minister and a leader,Yahya should not be throwing such words to another leader.It is not only morally wrong but degrading and put him at par to an ordinary people on the streets.Under no circumstances should a leader utter obscene,derogatory and humiliating words to another person.He should be calm and serene and above all remember where he stands and the position that he holds that to many are esteem and respectful.This is leadership by example.
Under the bn / umno regime, sabah has lost all of its natural resources to corrupted bn led govt and making the people suffer. As a DCM, Yahya should know this well unless he turns a blind eye on all these things and only wants to enjoy the ill gotten wealth for his self interest.He should assess himself first what he has done for the State and the people before calling other unpatriotic and what Sabah has benefit from the bn led govt rule ...poorest state, highest cost of living, backwards economically and underdeveloped state, Is this what bn led govt called 'benefit' to the people?
ReplyDeleteRight under his nose, the oil and gas is being siphoned out of the State, do you call yourselves together with your gang under bn patriotic. Come on be a man do the right thing.
The remarks that he uttered is only fitted for himself and that show his true color. Just like a thief, he will always deny he has not done any thing wrong by stealing from others.
semenjak membenarkan UMNO di Sabah, orang Sabah dalam UMNO dah jadi macam orang UMNO di Malaya.Memalukan, korupsi, merampas tanah adat orang Sabah.Masa untuk buang UMNO dari Sabah.
ReplyDeletePandai-pandailah kita sendiri menilai.
ReplyDeleteUndilah dengan bijak bila PRU-13 nanti.
ReplyDeleteCuri duit rakyat untok berjudi di sebuah casino di London patriotik ka! Phuiiii. UMNO saitan.
ReplyDeleteTiada guna bersopan santun dengan Para pemimpin BN/UMNO yang telah menjual negeri Sabah kepada PATI melalui projek IC Mahathir dengan kerjasama, Harris,Musa,Yahya,serta semua pemimpin BN asal PTI serta wakil2 rakyat BN/UMNO seperti Sairin Karno dari Keningau.
ReplyDeleteGo to Hell BN/UMNO! Kamu tidak layak digelar pemimpin tapi kamu sangat layak digelar penipu dan Penjahat!
UMNO adalah berasal dari Indonesia dan tidak lama lagi Sabah akan dijajah oleh Indonesia dan Philipina. Mereka akan bahagi dua ini negeri Sabah!
ReplyDeletePairin, Maximus, Kurup, Bumburing, Dompok dan semua pemimpin BN berbangsa KDM akan menari poco2 dan daling2 versi filifina.
Jadi, Umno memang patriotik! Sabah sedang dilelong pada fasa terakhir oleh UMNO .
Undilah UMNO supaya Sabah kita terlelong kepada Indon/Philipin.
SHAFIE, DARI PUTRAJAYA KE ISA?
ReplyDeleteKEHADIRAN 600 Perwakilan dan lebih 2,000 pemerhati UMNO Sabah di Pusat Dagangan Dunia Putera akan memberi impak yang cukup besar kepada Naib Presiden UMNO, Datuk Seri Panglima Mohd Shafie Haji Apdal yang menjadi fokus utama perwakilan sejak Ketua Audit Negara membentangkan laporannya di Parlimen pada 24 November 2011.
Walaupun laporan Ketua Audit Negara 2010 hanya menimbulkan isu remeh dan kecuaian akauntabiliti banyak Kementerian dan Jabatan, namun isu MARA dan Kementerian Kemajuan Luar Bandar dan Wilayah (KKLW), terutama dalam Projek NKRA Bekalan Elektrik Luar Bandar (BELB) menjadi isu prima yang dicanang begitu hebat, bukan sahaja oleh Wakil Pembangkang, malah oleh pemimpin UMNO.
sikap patriotik perlu ada dalam diri.
ReplyDeleterakyat pandai-pandailah menilai mana yang baik untuk mereka.
ReplyDeleteada saja isu yang ditimbulkan. apa pun, yang penting tanggungjawab kepada rakyat perlu sentiasa ditunaikan.
ReplyDeleteahli2 politik mana pernah buat komen yang jujur dan ikhlas.. wajib buat komen yang bersifat berat sebelah..
ReplyDeleteSetiap pemimpin kena tahu erti sebenar perkataan patriotik itu.
ReplyDeleteperbaiki kelemahan yang timbul. bukan hanya terus persoal dan pertikaikannya tanpa ada tindakan.
ReplyDeleteDunia politik ni, mengalahkan pentas gosip artis oo.. hhaa
ReplyDeletePatriotik atau tak hnaya empunya badan saja yang tahu. Jadi tak payahlah panjangkan hal ini.
ReplyDeletePaling penting rakyat harus bujak membuat penilaian dan jangan mudah terpedaya.
ReplyDeleteJusteru, undilah yang terbai PRU13 nanti. Jnagan pula kemudia hari baru mahu menyesal.
ReplyDeleteApapun, kita tunggu dan lihat sajalah nanti.
ReplyDeleteGeneral election is coming.
ReplyDeleteMacam mana isu ini boleh timbul?
ReplyDeleteBeing patriotic is not just for talks.
ReplyDeleteWe'll just wait and see how it goes after this, the next GE is almost near.
ReplyDeleteAll of us are not perfect.Lets forgive and forget and move on. This is only politics !! A game only.
ReplyDeleteThis is so subjective.
ReplyDeleteKalau nak pertikaikan parti lain, lihat dulu diri sendiri.
ReplyDeleteGood luck.
ReplyDeleteWhen come to election, all kind of question and comment flying here and there. Value and judge yourself.
ReplyDelete"if Umno is such a great planner in reviving the economy of the state, why did Sabah become the poorest state beginning with Umno’s the takeover of the state in 1994? Why has one company connected to a senior BN leader taken most of the road building projects in Sabah? And why are the people complaining about construction projects being usually overpriced by up to 100% their actual costs?"
ReplyDeleteBN seharus memberi penjelasan apa yang sedang berlaku. Kebanyakan kes yang dikemukakan itu tiada penyelesaiannya.
Indeed, this is way too subjective, not everyone in BN is good or not everyone in BN is bad either.. Similar to "patriotic".
ReplyDeletePlay our own role. Not a great idea to prejudice about some others.
ReplyDeleteAs about BN in Sabah, indeed more rooms of improvement. Hope the Wakil Rakyat play their role and be responsible to the people.
ReplyDeleteBN masih mampu untuk mentadbir Negara kita. Jadi selagi relevan apa salahnya kita teruskan menyokong parti tersebut.
ReplyDeleteSetiap orang ada kelemahan dan kelebihan mereka sendiri. Maka kita yang nampak kelemahan orang lain sebaiknya berikanlah terguran sebaiknya.
ReplyDeletePRU 13 semakin hampir..Jadi mari kita lihat siapakah yang akan menjadi pilihan rakyat pada akan datang.
ReplyDeletekritikan tidak semestinya benar..namun setiap kritikan yang dibuat pasti akan membina..jadi YB Yahya harus lebih profesional dan tidak hilang kewarasan..nanti dicakap pula sudah tidak relevan..fikir-fikirkanlah..
ReplyDeleteadakah setiap wakil rakyat yang dipilih melalui pilihanraya bersikap patriotik?
ReplyDeleterasanya setiap wakil rakyat tidak berhak untuk menuduh wakil rakyat lain sebagai tidak patriotik kerana mereka dipilih oleh rakyat...maka isu patriotik atau tidak tidak sepatutnya timbul di kalangan wakil rakyat baik kerajaan atau pembangkang..
ReplyDeleteuntuk membuktikan pemimpin2 sabah baik kerajaan atau pembangkang bersikap patriotik, tuntutan penubuhan RCI untuk menyiasat projek IC harus disokong sepenuhnya..
ReplyDeletetidak perlu perbesarkan hal ini...fokus kepada perkara yang lebih penting..
ReplyDelete“To the opposition like … Jimmy Wong, the budget today is meaningless … no matter how much the budget is it is incorrect… it is opposed in a way that is membabi buta (blindly)… when the opposition talks about Sabah, everything about it is bad but when they talk about other states such as Penang and Selangor, it is all good.”
ReplyDeletenothing to do with patrotic or what. its more to bias.
neway this is just a small matter. no need to make it a big deal. Instead of criticizing each other, better for both sides to "turun padang". GE is just around the corner.
ReplyDeleteAll the best to all parties. May the best man win!
ReplyDeleteYa musim dorian is just round the corner, so dorian can eat rotten UMNO Dorian then, PRU13! Because they sold Sabah dignity to the PTI who vote for the UMNO(FIX DEPOSIT)
ReplyDeleteUmno is not patriotic. Umno is corrupt. They are PTIs origin of leaders.
It depend how you define Patriotism...if you see Patriotism as a love for his/her state, opinion with those who see patriotism as a love for his/her country will be different...
ReplyDeleteSo which actor will you put your allegiance to? the state or the country?