Yong's flawed 'new hope' economic carried out in Free Malaysia Today dated January 21, 2012. As the writer claimed the excerpt appeared in Sabahkini.com was written by an ex-banker.
The rebuttal made by the ex-banker on Datuk Yong declared statement "the bond is like spending tomorrow's money today" of which the ex-banker claimed SAPP's ignorance of economic theory and the party's to understand the financial market.
The ex-banker goes beyond by bringing the issues such as the legality and the quality of the bonds. The superiority, rating AAA, as assigned by RAM (Rating Services Bhd) has never been the contention of Yong's arguments.
Actually, this ex-banker simply missed the whole point of contention. Datuk Yong had never question the superiority and the legality of the bonds issued.
The issue that need to be addressed, why does the State Government resorts of borrowing with RM3 billion in its consolidated fund. Why commit unnecessary debts when you have the money? Is it true that the State is really having the money?
The issue on how the financial market operates is understood but it is not the core of the subject. It is too difficult to comprehend on the rationality as to why the government willingly to spend extra cost of 4.58% annually on interests. What is the rationality of having high saving and unspent to the extent of borrowing? Has it been spent wisely to stimulate the economy or just only benefiting few cronies? Is the money spent in Sabah or outside the state? The most important issue on the real economic benefits derived from this money to the people of Sabah.
One shouldn't forget Sabah is one of the poorest States and out of 10 of its population 4 are poorest. This is a fact! Why is it so? Is that what you call as a sound and prudent financial policy? The answer is very simple even a layman in the kampong knows better. What is happening to Sabah basically is due to poor financial mismanagement and abuse of power. But what is amusing this particular ex-banker who claimed to have vast knowledge on financial markets is not the smartest after all. What he wrote merely skirting around to hoodwink and hiding facts.
He knew the state is managed by leaders that are only interested to harvest and pillage the wealth of Sabah. They do not have agendas to improve the livelihood of the people. So don't dream the GDP per capita will ever improve when the cost of living continues to increase. In the years to come more Sabahans will be in the state of hopelessness and in misery.
Now the next issue how the money raised was spent. Are the people of Sabah really economically benefiting from the projects undertaken, if so how, or is the money raised and loaned to private investors or cronies for private ventures. Just tell the people of Sabah on the real economic values derived from this money. That should prove your claimed that the government is transparent and accountable.
Every Sabahan pray hard and hope this money is not spent for easy loans on private investors that make it weird for the State government to act as a 'guarantor'. The worst scenario if those ventures are undertaken outside Sabah.
There is no need for him to drag and skirt around under the theory of financial market to substantiate something on the basis of lies and egocentric. Remember the bonds will mature in 2015 and the economic spin-offs as you mentioned none existed and only at his own imagination. What is obvious that you should acknowledge every Sabahans will share the burden to pay at lump sum upon its maturity period?
Yong's statement is not ignorance of economic theory or financial market but rather a reflection action by a responsible leader on how rakyat money should be spent wisely. It is a view of being realistic and responsible approach on how the public fund should be spent tactfully in accordance with the existing financial procedures.
SAPP understands well and will initiate various measures to alter the economy of the State as specified in its economic plan. SAPP firmly committed that the economic plan constitutes various measures to transform Sabah's economy and to propel the momentum of its growth at the desired rates.
SAPP will push the economy towards full employments; the Cabotage policy imposed must be stopped and other forms of monopoly and encourage open market competitions. Besides, in this era of globalization and liberalization, SAPP will make attempt to regulate business and industries that will benefit the business community of Sabahans. SAPP will seek quality investments from internal and foreign investors especially in the sectors and industries with value added and knowledge based investments.
SAPP realizes on the very importance of food production. SAPP will exploit and deploy our resources to the maximum especially in the production of rice. SAPP is fully committed that Sabah will achieve the status of self sufficiency in the production of rice by 2018.
SAPP's economic plan is not a gimmick but a realistic and achievable plan.
Dullie Haji Mari is Sabah Progressive Party (SAPP) Treasurer-General
O ya 'Datuk' Dullie if SAPP as government this round make sure YTL do something at least for his own home - Lahad Datu.
ReplyDeletePeople there is asking what had been done by him for LD?What a mess with the town planning there?
Look at the old airport...still the same look!
well well well, its looks like YTL is only good at talking but when it comes to helping his own hometown, there are no plans at all to develop LD.
DeleteSDMan, dia bilang si TYL 'terlepas pandang ba' everyone make mistake. LoL.
DeleteKalau sudah ada yang mengadu, mana boleh terlepas pandang lagi.
DeleteSaya tak faham lah apa Dullie cakap ni.Sekejap pasal bond sekejap lagi pasal beras,sekejap pasal kerja,sekejap pasal pelaburan,sekejap lagi pasal cabotage.Macam ada tak kena saja.Macam buat janji-janji kosong.Cuba buat perincian macam mana dapat SAPP tunaikan semua itu.Saya pun mau tau juga.
ReplyDeleteI'm agreeing with Anonymous, SAPP should show the people how they intended to achieve all they say.
Deletetak perlu nak terpengaruh dgn kata2 SAPP.
Deleteits all in the article if you really read and understand it.
DeleteIt is normal for the opposition to promise the moon and the stars because they know they cannot rule and they are not in government
DeleteLet it be fair. Give opportunity and space for both govt and opposition to convey their plans and promises. Let the rakyat be the audiences and judges.
Deletebuat keliru saja...tiada ketetapan..
DeleteDullie is just responding to the so-called ex banker who, out of the blue, came blazing his guns at Yong and SAPP and specifically talking on the controversial bond by the BN govt while keeping mum on the other bigger issues that the local party has outlined.
ReplyDeleteTo quote..."The issue that need to be addressed, why does the State Government resorts of borrowing with RM3 billion in its consolidated fund. Why commit unnecessary debts when you have the money? Is it true that the State is really having the money?" brings up a lot of unanswered questions, does it not?
Definitely brings up a lot of unanswere question. I think most people are eager to know. I wonder whether the so called ex banker would respond to Dullie.
DeleteIf out of ten Sabahans, four is poor. The four are most likely to be PTI.
ReplyDeletePTI yang menyumbang kepada kadar kemiskinan di Sabah.
Deleteone way to know for sure is to deport those PTIs back to their own country.
DeleteDeport today, another new PTIs come.
DeleteIs it really PTI?
Deletepati memang memberikan banyak masalah termasuklah menyumbang kepada kadar kemiskinan.
Deletethat's why the RCI need to be set up ASAP..
Delete"Why should Sabah use its own cash when it can borrow at a cost low enough to be offset by economic returns from the generation of NEW economic activities?"
ReplyDeleteWhere is Dullie's respond to this? He is producing more & more question & try to divert the point of discussion without countering the point...
sorry to say, but i think most of SAPP leaders, from branches to central, is a joke, except for a few like Amde Sidik...
I think its Dullie style of writing. he purposely do a divertion to make the so call ex banker look wrong in every ways.
DeleteOngkol,
ReplyDeleteI fully agree what you say except in SAPP there is no exception on their poor leadership calibre including Amdee Sidik.
"SAPP's economic plan is not a gimmick but a realistic and achievable plan."
ReplyDeleteKonfiden nampak... Bah, kita lihat sajalah nanti.
Gimik atau tidak, yang penting bila bercakap mengenainya kena nampak yakin supaya dapat tarik perhatian pengundi. Itu saja bah tu..hehe
Deletejust prove it.
Deletesemua parti pun mempunyai rancangan mereka sendiri..kita nilailah mana yang lebih baik.
DeleteSaya kurang arif pasal bab ni, so paling senang SAPP buktikan saja mcm mana mahu capai semua yg dorang kunun mahu capai tu...
ReplyDeleteSAPP cakap saja senang, SAS pun rugi pasal dia..
Deleteitu menunjukkan sapp pun bukanlah cekap sangat.
DeleteSaya rasa itu cara paling senang utk buat rakyat faham daripada ayik bg penjelasan melalui perkataan. hehhee
ReplyDeleteNamun ini mungkin usaha SAPP utk tambat hati rakyat, so all the best lah:)
ReplyDeleteYang penting bagi saya ialah penilaian rakyat. So nilailah sebaik mungkin dan buatlah apa yang patut.
ReplyDeletebetul, biar rakyat yang menilai mana yang baik.
Deleteongkol, jgn pura2 tidak fahm bah!!!!!!!......jgn malu2 ongkol............
ReplyDeletehahaha.....anonymous ego bah ongkal itu....bgus ongkol jdi prsident sapp....bukankah.klau tidak jdi govner bnk negra....kan kah baik?macm dullie setuju kah?
ReplyDeleteBeEnd Musang is a cunning businessman but not fit to be Sabah CM.
ReplyDeleteMusang don't feel ashame proudly to make Sabah the Poorest in Malaysia due to his incompetency and corruption. We do not need a PARIAH like him.
Musang says he has 3 bil RM in state coffer but he issue 500+ mil bond which simply indicated that 3 bil RM in state coffer is merely BULLSHITS!
Like those countries which is facing financial problems will issue bonds in order to raise fund because their financial coffer already dried up or KOSONG!
Only fools will believe this cunning Musang!!!
Musang thought we Sabahans never go to school and easily be conned by him.
I would rather support SAPP this time at least their economic plan is practical and viable.
What? Sabah UMNo claimed RM3 billion in state coffer but need to issue bond for what? He must be thinking we Sabahans are stupid. FCUK you umno!
ReplyDeleteongkol & paquin = ex banker....hehehehe....memeang ego betul anonymous...tngok saja posting dia diatas....konon pandai tapi palui.....manang ego sja.
ReplyDeleteGood to plan but only God knows what will happen to the world economic later.The impact on Malaysia...
ReplyDeleteGood to have independent party to vouch the transaction of what is going on. If the government is doing right. Nothing to worry about what Datuk Yong says , right??
Sapp economic plan is realistic as far as I am concerned and they are really sincerely in trying to get Sabah on the right economically path.
ReplyDeleteI have no doubt of Sapp's capability in this case and they should be given the golden chance! God Willing!
Dont attack me, im just stating the fact. Can some SAPP supporters here help their so-call treasurer general to rebut ex bankers statement below:
ReplyDelete"Why should Sabah use its own cash when it can borrow at a cost low enough to be offset by economic returns from the generation of NEW economic activities?"
dont be a typical SAPP supporters, only attack but no point being wrote. Thats like an accuse thief trying to stab his accuser without trying to defend himself from the accusation...
the Economic Transformation Programme (ETP) and the Government Transformation Programme (GTP) as diverse sectors propelling the economy to compete globally
DeleteI believe the people know how to evaluate between the good and bad
ReplyDeleteOngkol,
ReplyDelete"Why should Sabah use its own cash when it can borrow at a cost low enough to be offset by economic returns from the generation of NEW economic activities?"
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Show me how much is the interest charged to the bond buyer issued by Musang bin tidak aman and the interested charged by Sabah development bank when it comes to the maturity date of the bond. All this while musang bin tidak aman only talk cock but never reveal the figure.
Only those countries facing in financial crisis, they will issue bond to raise fund. Stop fooling the people!
GTP only applicable to Malaya but not Sabah!
ReplyDeleteUMNO is FAILED BIG TIME in Sabah and should send them back to malaya in this GE13.
You can ask UMNO PTI YB Sekong from Philipine Samsusudin yahya, What is Economic Transformation Progam? He replied " Apa itu" ? Aku tidak tahu. This is the quality of UMNO ybs!!!!
As the saying goes: If its too good to be true, then it is just is
ReplyDeleteThey should have walk the talk
ReplyDeleteDon't fall for promises for they are not foreseeable, and don't go for corrupted politicians.
ReplyDeletemasing-masing dengan pendapat sendiri..yang pasti semua parti kini berusaha untuk mendapat sokongan. jadi rakyat perlu bijak menilai.
ReplyDeletekita lihat sama ada SAPP akan jadi pilihan rakyat atau tidak..
ReplyDeleteSAPP tidak perlu risau dengan BN Sabah. Namun apa yang kita tahu pada PRU 13 Barisan Nasional akan menang dan ini tidak dapat dinafikan namun jumlah kerusi yang BN menang itu akan meningkat ataupun menurun tidak dapat dipastikan. BN tetap menang dan itu hakikatnya dan pihak pembangkang tahu akan hal ini maka janganlah pura-pura lagi dan cuba untuk memberikan janji terang bulan dan memberikan pelbagai gimik meraih sokongan..
ReplyDeleteKerajaan BN negeri Sabah sentiasa komited untuk mencapai sasaran yang kita rancang melalui disiplin kewangan dan perbelanjaan yang teratur.
ReplyDeleteSasaran jangka panjang kita untuk menjadi negeri yang maju dan makmur pasti dicapai kerana fundamental ekonomi adalah kukuh ditambah lagi dengan kekayaan hasil bumi negeri ini.
Maka jika dengan apa yang dinyatakan oleh SAPP seperti menunjukkan ekonomi Sabah sangat lemah. Namun sebenarnya mereka tidak tahu akan perkara ini sebab hanya kerajaan Negeri BN sabah yang tahu akan usaha pengurusan yang dibuat.
Dengan pengurusan yang dibuat oleh kerajaan NEgeri Sabah sendiri menampakan membuat pengurusan dengan baik. Ini kerana Sabah merupakan antara negeri yang terbaik dalam pengurusan kewangan dengan mempertahankan Sijil Bersih yang dianugerahkan oleh Ketua Audit Negara selama 11 tahun berturut-turut.
ReplyDeleteMencapai penarafan tertinggi “AAA” oleh RAM Rating Services Berhad selama 3 tahun berturut-turut kerana kedudukan fiskal negeri yang mantap dengan lebihan yang berterusan dan mengumpulkan rizab yang kukuh di samping hubungan baik dan sokongan padu daripada Kerajaan Pusat.
Mendapat persijilan ISO oleh Moody International untuk pengurusan bajet negeri yang efisien dan teratur bagi tempoh 3 tahun berturut-turut.
Jadi mungkin banyak yang tidak tahu akan perkara ini dan ada yang pura-pura seperti pembangkang seperti SAPP sendiri.
BN Sabah telah merancang dengan memberikan tumpuan peruntukan-peruntukan bagi tahun 2012 akan dibelanjakan dengan beberapa objektif dan strategi iaitu seperti berikut:
ReplyDelete-mengukuhkan kewangan negeri.
-mengekalkan momentum ekonomi negeri.
-menambah baik infrastruktur asas dan kemudahan awam.
-mempercepatkan pencapaian halatuju.
-membangunkan belia dan modal insan yang berkualiti dan bernilai.
-menghapuskan kemiskinan.
-pembangunan seimbang antara kawasan.
Ini cuma sedikit dari perancangan yang dibuat. Rasanya masih banyak perancang dan pelan ekonomi yang dibuat oleh BN. Jika kita bandingkan kerajaan dengan SAPP. Rasanya kita pasti sedar mana yang boleh melakukan dan mana yang tidak. SAPP dulu pernah menjadi KM sabah juga, namun tidak ada yang menarik dibuat oleh SAPP.
Pelan ekonomi presiden SAPP Datuk Yong Teck Lee, yang berkata, pelan itu dirangka berikutan respons orang ramai yang bertanya apa yang boleh dilakukan parti itu untuk Sabah sekiranya ia mengambil alih kerajaan Negeri.
ReplyDeleteNamun tidak semestinya apa yang dikatakan itu benar-benar berlaku, itu cuma atas kertas semata-mata. Janji tinggal janji. Memang itu respon dari orang ramai, namun apa yang SAPP lakukan itu cuma antara persoalan dan juga jawapan. Orang ramai membuat persoalan, maka SAPP memberikan jawapan. Namun jawapan tidak semestinya 100% betul dan terlaksana kerana itu cuma ada dikertas dan keluar dari mulut.
Jika benar Ekonomi Plan yang SAPP cadangakan, ini akan membawa Sabah ke peringkat yang lebih maju.
ReplyDeleteEknomi membangun terus menyelessaikan masalah kemiskinan.
ReplyDeleteHarap SAPP dapat menjalankan apa yang ditunaikan.
ReplyDeleteEkonomi membangun, yang memanfaatkan adalah rakyat juga. Tidak harus bersikap negatif terhadap perancangan tersebut.
ReplyDeleteHarap SAPP tidak menggunakan ekonomi plan ini semata-mata untuk menambat hati rakyat.
ReplyDeleteJika bujet 2012 diuruskan dengan baik, pasti satu imej baru untuk negeri Sabah.
ReplyDeleteProgram untuk pembangunan ekonomi memang harus dijalankan agar masalah kemiskinan dapat diperbaiki.
ReplyDeleteIm sure BN willdo more for the expansion of local economy.
ReplyDeleteEkonomi berkembang, rakyat turut mendapat manfaat. Syukur jika semua ini menjadi kenyataan.
ReplyDeletehanya bila dekat2 pilihanraya baru tampil dengan plan ekonomi.. bukan boleh dikategorikan sebagai gula2 pilihanraya ka ni..
ReplyDeletemasa YTL jadi KM Sabah, dia tiada buat plan ekonomi ka? patut la banyak masalah timbul..
ReplyDeleteAction speaks louder than mere words…it should all be practiced.
ReplyDeleteI suppose just fairness for both government and oppositions will eventually lead into expressing their plans, promises and great value for the people as claimed.
ReplyDeleteHope their plans are for the benefits of the people.
ReplyDeleteWhatever plans they have, hope it will boost up the economy of Sabah.
ReplyDeleteTime will eventually tell and unfold the truth.
ReplyDelete